Digital transformation of municipal public services remains uneven in transition economies, while national e-government indices often obscure substantial disparities across cities. This study develops a composite E-Government Maturity and Performance Index (EGMPI) to evaluate eleven Armenian municipalities across four governance dimensions: digital service availability, administrative efficiency, transparency and accountability, and citizen interaction and participation. Using publicly available data for Q1 2024, the analysis reveals pronounced metropolitan concentration, with large cities significantly outperforming smaller municipalities. Although performance correlates with population size and fiscal capacity, institutional and managerial factors strongly mediate outcomes, as comparable municipalities display substantial differences in service maturity. Results further show that local governments tend to prioritize transparency measures over functional efficiency, indicating symbolic digitalization rather than substantive service transformation. Unlike national e-government indices, this study provides a city-level diagnostic framework enabling intra-country performance comparison and actionable municipal policy design. Based on the findings, a multi-level policy roadmap is proposed, including shared national platforms, regional digital hubs, targeted capacity building, and leapfrogging strategies for low-maturity cities. The proposed governance-oriented framework offers a replicable tool for transition economies and demonstrates that effective digital transformation depends primarily on institutional coordination and citizen-centric management rather than financial resources alone.
This study examines the transformative role of digital and artificial intelligence (AI)-enabled public procurement systems in enhancing governance efficiency within smart city environments, with a specific focus on Yerevan, Armenia. As urban administrations increasingly adopt data-driven governance models and digital infrastructures, public procurement remains a critical yet underexplored domain for innovation in transition economies. Despite ongoing e-government reforms in Armenia, procurement systems continue to face challenges related to procedural inefficiencies, limited transparency, and institutional constraints. To address these challenges, the paper develops a Governance Efficiency Framework that integrates digitalization, AI capabilities, and multi-criteria decision-making principles to assess and optimize public procurement processes in urban settings. The framework incorporates key dimensions such as transparency, operational efficiency, accountability, and data integration, enabling a comprehensive evaluation of procurement performance. The empirical application of the framework to the case of Yerevan provides insights into the structural and technological determinants of procurement efficiency in a transition economy context. The findings indicate that while digitalization has contributed to improvements in transparency, significant limitations remain in efficiency and system integration. A scenario-based analysis further suggests that AI-enabled analytics, process automation, and digital procurement platforms have the potential to reduce administrative delays, enhance transparency, and support more strategic and evidence-based decision-making under assumed implementation conditions. By bridging the fields of public procurement, digital governance, and smart city research, this study contributes both theoretically and practically. It offers a structured and adaptable framework for policymakers and urban administrators seeking to modernize procurement systems and strengthen governance efficiency in evolving digital environments.