The aim of this article is to explore Norwegian family counselors´ professional assessments when children are at potential risk due to enduring parental disputes. These disputes present complex clinical challenges and are often considered being in a gray area of whether the situation is a family matter or if there is a need for the assessment of child welfare services. The analysis builds on a survey and focus group interviews. Findings from this study show that family counselors are concerned for children involved in interparental conflicts, but this concern does not necessarily manifest in their reporting to the child welfare services. Rather, our findings show that the family counselors prefer to utilize their own services and that of other stakeholders in such situations. Enduring conflicts present significant challenges relating to the assessments and decisions of what is the most adequate help for the unique child and family. The article points toward professional thresholds for intervention and risk of child maladjustment as a challenging aspect of practice in high-conflict cases.
This study explores judges’ experiences of assessing parental high-conflict cases in Norwegian courts, focusing on dilemmas in applying the principle of the child’s best interests. Twelve judges from district and appellate courts in Norway were interviewed using a semi-structured guide, and the data were analysed using reflexive thematic analysis. The findings show that these cases are characterised by persistent complexity, including polarised parental perspectives, challenges in determining the “truth”, and uncertainty about the long-term outcomes. We discuss these dilemmas through the lens of wicked problems theory, highlighting how legal processes often struggle to address multifaceted and evolving conflicts. The study underscores the need for flexible approaches and interdisciplinary collaboration to safeguard children’s well-being in high-conflict custody disputes. However, children need stability during lengthy legal proceedings.