Environmental DNA (eDNA) metabarcoding methods have demonstrated their potential as noninvasive techniques for the monitoring and conservation of marine fishes, including rare and endangered taxa. However, the majority of these investigations have focused on large‐bodied taxa such as sharks and sturgeons. In contrast, eDNA studies on small‐bodied cryptic taxa are much less common. As a case in point, seahorses (members of the Syngnathidae family) have never been detected by eDNA, despite the fact that globally there are 14 species classified as “Threatened” by the IUCN. Here, we critically evaluate the ability of two existing broad‐spectrum fish metabarcoding assays (MiFish and 16S Fish) and explore the efficacy of two newly designed fish metabarcoding assays (16S_FishSyn_Short and 16S_FishSyn_Long) to detect Syngnathidae amidst a wide spectrum of fish species. Furthermore, a custom Western Australian 16S rRNA fish database was created to increase the likelihood of correct taxonomic assignments. With the newly designed assays, we detected four Syngnathidae species in a targeted eDNA survey of the Perth metropolitan area (Western Australia). These detections include the seahorse species Hippocampus subelongatus and Hippocampus breviceps, which represents the first time seahorse species have been detected using eDNA. The existing MiFish and 16S Fish assays did not detect any Syngnathidae. This evaluation of all four fish metabarcoding assays reinforces the view that every PCR assay has “blind spots”. In the context of complex environmental samples, no assay is universal and false negatives will occur due to a combination of PCR efficacy, primer binding, assay sensitivity, degeneracies in the primers, template competition, and amplicon length. Taken together, these data indicate that eDNA methodologies, with ongoing optimizations, will become an integral part of monitoring small‐bodied cryptic taxa such as seahorses, gobies, and blennies and can assist in mapping species’ distributions and prioritizing conservation areas.
The effective management of rare and threatened species, especially in areas where population sizes have diminished, relies on knowledge of their population size, threats, and distribution. Robust mapping of distribution presents a particular challenge in aquatic environments for cryptic species, especially those with low abundance. Environmental DNA (eDNA) approaches can offer improved detection rates of many rare and threatened species when compared with traditional sampling approaches. In this study, we developed and optimized a targeted eDNA assay for the critically endangered estuarine pipefish (Syngnathus watermeyeri). eDNA sampling and seine netting were undertaken at 39 sites across the historical range of S. watermeyeri in the Eastern Cape of South Africa in 2019. At each site, five water samples were collected for eDNA analysis (n = 195) along with three seine netting hauls (n = 117). Habitat and environmental data were collected at each location to explore what physical and biotic parameters might correlate with pipefish presence/absence. We successfully detected S. watermeyeri in two estuaries (Kariega and Bushmans) using both survey methods. Importantly, the positive detection rate of eDNA (66.7%) was four times that of seine netting (16.7%), highlighting the value of eDNA as a monitoring tool for rare and cryptic species. Null detections in the Kasouga, East Kleinemonde, and West Kleinemonde estuaries add to the growing body of evidence that the estuarine pipefish has been extirpated from these locations and is now only found in two estuarine systems. The occurrence of S. watermeyeri was found to be highly dependent on the cover of submerged macrophytes such as Zostera capensis (eelgrass). By providing a more complete picture of the conservation status of this critically endangered species, this work facilitates the development of a long‐term monitoring program and the identification of priority conservation areas.
Antarctic krill (Euphausia superba) is a keystone species in the Southern Ocean ecosystem, and monitoring its distribution and abundance is crucial for the sustainable management of expanding fisheries targeting the species. Environmental DNA (eDNA)‐based monitoring could complement conventional krill surveys, but its applicability is limited by a lack of knowledge on eDNA persistence and decay in the Southern Ocean. We aimed to develop a method that can not only quantify Antarctic krill eDNA, but also estimate a relative time since this eDNA was shed (“recent” vs “older”). Three species‐specific qPCR markers targeting the mitochondrial 16S region were developed, and the eDNA decay characteristics of these markers were determined through tank experiments. Krill eDNA was partially degraded in all samples, even when krill were present. Marker concentrations decreased exponentially at similar rates after krill removal, with initial relative abundances maintained across the three markers. Over time, the concentration of the longest marker decreased faster, changing the relative abundances of the markers, and allowing discrimination of more recent samples from more degraded older samples. We employed this new method to quantify Antarctic krill eDNA collected across a 4800 km Southern Ocean transect, and estimated the age of the eDNA in these samples based on the relative abundance of markers, adding a temporal aspect to a quantitative eDNA survey. We also compared a Euphausiid‐specific metabarcoding marker to the qPCR method to assess sensitivity in detecting Antarctic krill eDNA. While these new eDNA methods should be evaluated against existing non‐molecular survey methods, they could add an important novel, dynamic layer of information to future krill surveys. Our method could not only determine where Antarctic krill eDNA is present but shed light on how they may be using certain habitats, expanding our understanding of this important species’ life cycle and contributing to more accurate abundance and distribution estimates.
Environmental DNA (eDNA) metabarcoding is a widely used tool for surveying marine vertebrate biodiversity. To this end, many computational tools have been released and a plethora of bioinformatic approaches are used for eDNA‐based community composition analysis. Simulation studies and careful evaluation of taxonomic classifiers are essential to establish reliable benchmarks to improve the accuracy and reproducibility of eDNA‐based findings. Here we present a comprehensive evaluation of nine taxonomic classifiers exploring three widely used mitochondrial markers (12S rDNA, 16S rDNA and COI) in Australian marine vertebrates. Curated reference databases and exclusion database tests were used to simulate diverse species compositions, including three positive control and two negative control datasets. Using these simulated datasets ranging from 36 to 302 marker genes, we were able to identify between 19% and 89% of marine vertebrate species using mitochondrial markers. We show that MMSeqs2 and Metabuli generally outperform BLAST with 10% and 11% higher F1 scores for 12S and 16S rDNA markers, respectively, and that Naive Bayes Classifiers such as Mothur outperform sequence‐based classifiers except MMSeqs2 for COI markers by 11%. Database exclusion tests reveal that MMSeqs2 and BLAST are less susceptible to false positives compared to Kraken2 with default parameters. Based on these findings, we recommend that MMSeqs2 is used for taxonomic classification of marine vertebrates given its ability to improve species‐level assignments while reducing the number of false positives. Our work contributes to the establishment of best practices in eDNA‐based biodiversity analysis to ultimately increase the reliability of this monitoring tool in the context of marine vertebrate conservation.
Submarine canyons are globally recognized as biodiversity hotspots, yet logistical challenges in accessing deep‐sea environments hinder comprehensive surveys of their biota. This study presents the first extensive environmental DNA (eDNA) survey of the Cape Range and Cloates submarine canyons in the East Indian Ocean, integrating eDNA metabarcoding, remotely operated vehicle (ROV) imagery, and specimen collection to develop curated DNA reference sequences. Two metabarcoding assays (COI Leray and 16S Fish) were applied to 178 ten‐liter water samples collected across 5 depths: surface, 200, 500, 1000 m, and bottom (1750–4540 m). These assays detected 226 species spanning 126 families, with each canyon revealing unique species. Notably, our study identified 83 putative new records or range extensions, including a range extension for the sleeper shark ( Somniosus ) and the elusive giant squid ( Architeuthis dux ), and the first Western Australian record of the faceless cusk eel ( Typhlonus nasus ). We also detected deep‐diving mammals, including the pygmy sperm whale ( Kogia breviceps ) and Cuvier's beaked whale ( Ziphius cavirostris ). Our results revealed strong assay‐specific differences in vertical stratification patterns, with clear depth‐related signals in the COI Leray dataset and weaker, broad‐scale separation in the 16S Fish dataset. These disparities likely reflect the biological characteristics of the target taxa for each assay, as well as the dynamic nature of submarine canyons influencing vertical mixing. Together, these findings highlight the complexity of interpreting spatial biodiversity patterns using eDNA and the necessity of considering biological, ecological, and physical context of both target taxa and environment in future studies. Our work demonstrates the efficacy of eDNA metabarcoding in exploring submarine canyon biodiversity and its potential for characterizing biodiversity in unexplored deep‐sea habitats. The implementation of eDNA metabarcoding in deep‐sea research shows promise as a tool for establishing ecological baselines and informing conservation practices as growing anthropogenic pressures threaten these unique ecosystems.
Environmental DNA (eDNA) metabarcoding is a widely used tool for surveying marine vertebrate biodiversity. To this end, many computational tools have been released and a plethora of bioinformatic approaches are used for eDNA-based community composition analysis. Simulation studies and careful evaluation of taxonomic classifiers are essential to establish reliable benchmarks to improve accuracy and reproducibility of eDNA-based findings. Here we present a comprehensive evaluation of nine taxonomic classifiers exploring three widely used mitochondrial markers (12S rDNA, 16S rDNA, and COI) in Australian marine vertebrates. Curated reference databases and exclusion database tests were used to simulate diverse species compositions, including three positive control and two negative control datasets. Using these simulated datasets, we were able to identify between 19% to 85% of marine vertebrate species using mitochondrial markers. We show that MMSeqs2 and Metabuli generally outperform BLAST with 10% and 11% higher F1 scores for 12S and 16S rDNA markers, respectively, and that Naive Bayes Classifiers such as Mothur outperform sequence-based classifiers except MMSeqs2 for COI markers by 11%. Database exclusion tests reveal that MMSeqs2 and BLAST are less susceptible to false positives compared to Kraken2 with default parameters. Based on these findings, we recommend that MMSeqs2 is used for taxonomic classification of marine vertebrates given its ability to improve species-level assignments while reducing the number of false positives. Our work contributes to the establishment of best practices in eDNA-based biodiversity analysis to ultimately increase the reliability of this monitoring tool in the context of marine vertebrate conservation.