This study concerns the evolution of flow field and hydrodynamic characteristics within the developing scour hole around a four-pile group with 2 × 2 arrangement. The instantaneous velocities in scour holes at four typical stages during the scouring process were measured by an acoustic Doppler velocimeter (ADV). The evolution and spatial distribution of the time-averaged flow field, turbulence, and the corresponding hydrodynamic characteristics within scour holes were compared. The time-averaged flow field shows that the reverse flow, downward flow, and horseshoe vortex are formed in the upstream of the pile group. During the scouring process, the mean components of flow characteristics (i.e., mean velocity, vorticity, and bed shear stress) around the pile group decrease while the fluctuating components (i.e., turbulence intensity) intensify simultaneously. Similarity of turbulence intensity profiles was found within different scour holes. The horseshoe vortex at upstream of each pile merges and the shear layer in the gap region extends when the dimension of the scour hole increases to that of equilibrium scour status, indicating that the four piles behave more like a single bluff body. With the development of scour holes, the large-scale horseshoe vortex system becomes more stable and the dissipation of small-scale eddies becomes more significant.
Previous literature has shown unsatisfactory validation of the existing equations predicting pier-scour depth with laboratory and field data. In an attempt to find the reasons for the unsatisfactory comparisons, we examined the performance of the Chinese equations with several other equations through in-depth analyses of the errors and explored the possible error-causing factors both in field measurement data and the proper use of parameters. Results show that the Chinese equations underpredicted scour depth for all the laboratory data and for field data under clear-water conditions. The Chinese equations performed better for field data under live-bed conditions compared to the other (i.e., laboratory, or clear-water field) conditions. The other equations overpredicted scour depth for both laboratory and field data. Uncertainty of the field data associated with measurement accuracy results in large errors, especially when scour depth is less than 1 m. The flood duration in the field is usually far shorter than what is needed to reach the equilibrium scour depth that the equations are attempting to predict for safe design, which contributes to the larger predicted scour depth than measurements. The effect of some parameters (e.g., sediment size, pier width, and incipient velocity for local pier scour) should be modified in the Chinese equations under fine-sediment and/or wide-pier conditions.
Accurate modelling of near-wall turbulence influenced by roughness is crucial in hydraulic engineering. This study presents modifications on the k-ϵ turbulence model for open-channel flows over rough bed based on reliable particle image velocimetry data. Experiments have been conducted for different roughness heights. Some near-wall turbulence characteristics (e.g. bursting events) are identified and the profiles of mean streamwise velocity, Reynolds shear stress and turbulence intensities are validated with direct numerical simulation data. Experimental results confirm that the coefficient cμ involved in the k-ϵ model varies with roughness Reynolds number in outer region, and with both and y+ (normalized distance from the wall) in near-wall region. A new damping function is reconstructed, and the profile of turbulent kinetic energy close to the wall is analytically obtained. The present modifications accounting for wall roughness effects are further implemented into the k-ϵ model and validation shows that the prediction accuracy for the near-wall flow has been improved.