Innovative small and medium-sized enterprises (SMEs) in European Widening Countries face persistent financing gaps, yet empirical evidence on how modern financing instruments shape post-investment performance trajectories remains scarce. This study applies a decision tree classification approach to examine post-investment revenue growth of 57 innovative SMEs across twelve European Widening Countries that received alternative financing grants, venture capital, business angel investment, or crowdfunding—between 2020 and 2022. Two research questions are addressed: which pre-investment firm characteristics predict revenue growth following modern financing, and how does the initial revenue level shape post-investment performance trajectories over a three-year observation window. Variable importance analysis indicates that pre-investment revenue level accounts for 83.9% of the predictive importance in the CART model, with development stage as the only secondary predictor (16.1%). Financing type was not identified as a discriminative predictor within the present sample. Low-revenue firms benefit most consistently from alternative financing, advancing an average of 1.51 revenue categories over three years, with 82.9% of firms exhibiting a growth trajectory. Medium-revenue firms exhibit a delayed growth pattern; and higher-revenue firms show persistent stagnation, suggesting a possible ceiling effect in post-investment revenue growth. The RQ1 model achieved cross-validated accuracy of 65.0%; the RQ2 model achieved 38.3%, reflecting the complexity of predicting four trajectory categories from a limited sample. These findings suggest that pre-investment firm characteristics may warrant greater attention alongside financing type when interpreting post-investment SME performance in Widening Country ecosystems. Complementary Logistic Regression and Random Forest analyses yielded broadly consistent results, providing additional support for the robustness of the reported findings.