State-level governing boards (SLGBs) can play an essential regulatory role as intermediaries between the public, state-elected officials, and campus-level leadership. However, these boards have been understudied within higher education relative to their enormous potential to influence postsecondary institutions and state political dynamics via the ways they engage and leverage political discourse in the agenda setting process. To explore this latent function, the authors analyze strategic plans generated by SLGBs of 33 states to theorize how these entities leverage economic, public purpose, and accountability discourses in the policymaking process. The overarching questions were: 1) what are the dominant discourses in SLGB strategic plans and 2) to which audience are these plans directed? The authors build on the concepts of collaborative governance and the Policy Streams Model of Decentralization Agenda Setting to illuminate and contextualize dimensions of the potential for SLGBs to operate as important policy actors. The authors present a conceptual framework that can help scholars better understand how SLGBs and policy discourses interact to achieve institutional and state priorities. Implications for policymakers engaging in strategic planning are also included.
17 June 2022 in International Journal of STEM Education
There is inconclusive evidence on the ability of scientific research in science, technology, engineering, and mathematics (STEM) education to scale-up from one context to another and ultimately become institutionalized. The dearth of evidence draws focus on how organizations change and evolve or the process of organizational learning. We designed this systematic review of the literature to uncover to what extent and how organizational theory has been leveraged within STEM interventions or as a research tool to inform the policies and practices of STEM education organizations. Unlike previous reviews, we explicitly focused on how organizational learning informs cultural transformation toward the success of racially and ethnically underrepresented minority (URM) students in STEM. The research question was: How has organizational theory and learning informed the potential for STEM education to center the success of URM students? Our results reveal that STEM entities that did not leverage organizational theory consistently fell into either the “decision trap” identified by Langely et al. created by ignoring temporal structures or deemed the innovation threatening, as Kezar suggested. We conclude with practical recommendations for the design of STEM education interventions.
15 December 2019 in Journal of Engineering Education
Faculty and administrators at postsecondary institutions continue to grapple with understanding the dynamic nature of student activism. In response, the National Survey of Student Engagement administered a supplemental item set following the 2016 presidential election, in which more than 3,000 respondents were asked about their involvement in activism. Leveraging these data, this study employed multilevel modeling to measure the relationship between activist behaviors and student backgrounds, high-impact practice (HIP) participation, involvement in student activities, and institutional characteristics. The present study adds nuance to and models the connection among HIPs, student identities (e.g., queer, black or African American), and student activism. Implications for practice and research are shared that outline a renewed understanding of student activism as a pillar of civic learning and democratic engagement work in higher education.
1 August 2024 in Journal of Diversity in Higher Education