The present narrative synthesis summarizes perspectives on the development of identity, or a sense of self, and the intersectionality of salient factors related to individuals who are d/Deaf and hard of hearing. Prior research indicates that identity encompasses the stories of an individual’s experiences and relationships; identity development may not be static but rather dynamic and ongoing throughout an individual’s lifetime. After this general background, the article focuses on identity and deafness, particularly for children in K-12 educational settings. There are a multitude of factors—physiological (e.g., hearing acuity, appearance, gender), psychological (e.g., memory, intelligence, affective behaviors), and social (e.g., education, home or immigrated environment, ethnicity, group membership)—that contribute to the development of identity. This discussion is based on a synthesis of a variety of published sources; however, as much as possible, the focus is on empirical research conducted with children and young adults who are d/Deaf and hard of hearing. Results of the narrative synthesis suggest several topics around which the extant research coalesce: traditional and evolving views of d/Dhh identity, d/Dhh identity as fluid, identity development through relationships, identity and children with cochlear implants and those who are hard of hearing, the role of educational experiences, and intersectional identity development. The article concludes with a summary and recommendations for further investigation.
As indicated in this Special Issue, there has been much debate on the development of English language and literacy in d/Deaf and hard of hearing (d/Dhh) students. Questions remain on the nature of the first language and the relation of this language to the development of English literacy. There is also considerable controversy on the role of English phonology. Adding to the complexity is the increase of d/Dhh children for whom English is not the home language and the ongoing challenge of addressing the needs of those with disabilities or additional disabilities. After describing English literacy and the need for documenting desirable research characteristics, the authors of this conclusion article utilize a construct named the Qualitative Similarity Hypothesis (QSH) as the guiding framework for addressing issues such as the role of phonology and the nature of the through-the-air form of the language of print. The QSH asserts that d/Dhh students need to master the same set of fundamentals as typical English literacy learners. These fundamentals include code-related, language-related, and comprehension-related skills. One major assertion is that proficiency in the through-the-air form of English is essential for achieving proficiency in conventional English literacy skills. It is argued that the importance of English language proficiency has been emphasized in literacy models that delineate the strong connections among language, reading, and writing, even for second language learners of English or English learners. Another major assertion is that proficiency in English phonology is necessary (albeit not sufficient) for the development of emerging decoding skills. The use of English phonology facilitates the early and advanced literacy comprehension skills. The article concludes with recommendations for additional research, including the understanding of the visual representation of the structure of English, the development of comprehensive English language assessments, and the exploration of literacy-related skills such as decoding and comprehension. Finally, the validity of the QSH also needs to be further investigated.
15 March 2006 in Journal of Deaf Studies and Deaf Education
This article is a response to Blue Listerine, Parochialism, and ASL Literacy (Czubek, 2006). The author presents his views on the concepts of literacy and the new and multiple literacies. In addition, the merits of print literacy and other types of literacies are discussed. Although the author agrees that there is an American Sign Language (ASL) literacy, he maintains that there should be a distinction between conversational “literacy” forms (speech and sign) and secondary literacy forms (reading and writing). It might be that cognitive skills associated with print literacy and, possibly, other captured literacy forms, are necessary for a technological, scientific-driven society such as that which exists in the United States.
In a previous editorial, I provided a few brief remarks about a complicated concept—critical thinking (Paul, 2018). In the present article, I attempt to unpack this construct a little further to explore the challenges of understanding and developing critical thinking skills. Here are a few questions for reflection: What does it mean to be a critical thinker? Can one be a "good" or "bad" critical thinker? Or, is it more appropriate to inquire whether an individual can be a "broad" or "narrow" critical thinker? Is it possible to teach critical thinking skills? Is it possible to "evaluate" a person's critical thinking abilities in an objective manner? In this so- called post- postmodern age (i.e., the era after postmodernism), is critical thinking a noble endeavor (e.g., necessary for a participatory democracy or advancing knowledge) or a hopeless cause (i.e., impossible due to relativistic worldviews or subjective approaches to knowledge)?
1 July 1998 in Journal of Deaf Studies and Deaf Education
Peter V. Paul; Introduction to the Special Issue on Literacy, The Journal of Deaf Studies and Deaf Education, Volume 3, Issue 3, 1 July 1998, Pages 177–178, ht
The question "What's it like to be deaf?" has engendered debates on whether deafness should be considered a loss, a gain, or both. It is doubtful that many scholars would agree that an adequate answer entails only a depiction of the degree of hearing acuity or loss, perhaps in conjunction with age at onset, thresholds for speech (i.e., for a spoken language), and hearing reception and comprehension. This might be a reasonable place to start, but it might not be the place to stop. Nevertheless, considering deafness as a hearing disability and focusing on attempts to remedy it through the development of spoken language(s) and literacy (or literacies) of mainstream society is deemed an appropriate route by a number of researchers, educators, and parents/caregivers (Paul & Moores, 2010; see also Wang & Andrews, 2014, 2015, for various perspectives on developing English literacy).