Train derailment can mainly cause not only economic losses in the shape of mangled rolling stock or infrastructure, but also more severely in causalities and disruptions of operations, yielding great impact on the sustainable development of railway industry. Considering various complex and symmetrical operational environments, as well as the characteristics of low frequency and high consequences of derailment accidents, risk response is undoubtedly underlined as one of the most critical components of risk management process. However, in practice, risk response does not receive enough attention in comparison with risk assessment that it lacks mature models and tools for selecting optimal strategy. This study constructs an integrated Multi Criteria Decision-Making (MCDM) model for the selection of optimum train derailment risk response strategy for the first time. In the model, decision making trial and evaluation laboratory (DEMATEL) technology is connected with analytical network process (ANP) to obtain evaluation criteria and their relative weights, and both of the two methods can deal with the complex coupling relationship between the indicators in the system. Then, technique for order performance by similarity to ideal solution (TOPSIS) is proposed to screen the optimum plan in the proposed model. Further, the Delphi method is used through the whole process to acquire expert advice. In the end, this model is used to select shunting derailment risk response strategies in Huangyangcheng station, and the final results demonstrate that this technology is simple and practical, and can provide a credible and practical tool for railway safety managers and engineers to choose the best risk response strategy.
Railway special line shunting safety is a complicated systemic topic, which is full of uncertainty and dynamic; safety is determined by numerous aspects, including human, management, environmental, and equipment factors. Many railway risk assessment techniques currently used are comparatively mature tools. However, in many circumstances, the application of these tools gives unsatisfactory results because the risk data are incomplete or involve high levels of uncertainty. Because risk assessment technology has its own applicability that it may not suitable for the three sub-processes of risk assessment, it is difficult to obtain ideal effects by using a single tool in the risk assessment process. This paper presents an integrated approach for conducting special-line shunting risk assessment, using fishbone diagram analysis, fuzzy reasoning approaches, and a fuzzy analytical hierarchy tool, which can evaluate both qualitative and quantitative risk data efficiently and effectively. The outcomes of risk assessment are represented as risk degrees and risk levels, providing railway safety risk managers and engineers with tools to improve their safety management standards. A case study is used to demonstrate the proposed methodology. The results reveal that the proposed model can effectively and efficiently assess risks associated with a special-line shunting system, yielding more reliable and realistic solutions.
Shunting operation is risky and complex because of the nonlinear coupling effect of personnel, equipment, environment and management, which reflects symmetry, can easily cause shunting derailment accidents. Traditional railway safety risk assessment techniques seldom consider the nonlinear coupling relationships of hazard factors in the shunting process,. The Decision Making Trial and Evaluation Laboratory (DEMATEL) and Analytic Network Process (ANP), which are applicable to the coupling analysis of complex systems, have been used in many areas to overcome this shortcoming. Thus, this paper built a hybrid model, developed by integrating DEMATEL and ANP methodologies, to determine the multifarious interdependencies’ relative strengths among the hazard factors and to assess the relative importance of the hazard factors with Super Decision (SD) software. By constructing the “frequency-consequence-vulnerability” three-dimensional risk parameter model, the risk magnitude of shunting derailment could be obtained through risk aggregation process. Finally, the model was applied to the risk assessment of shunting derailment in Huangyangcheng station, the results revealed that this model was effective and efficient, which could yield more reliable and realistic solutions to the shunting safety.
In the train operation department, humans are the most important and dynamic element, and their safe behavior is directly related to the safety of railway transportation. How to accurately assess the safety behavior risk of on-site workers is an urgent problem to be solved. In risk practice, some scholars directly use the accident potential data to calculate the risk parameters, and the accuracy of the risk magnitude is greatly affected by the data quality. Second, the traditional two-dimensional matrix only considers two external factors, probability and severity, without an in-depth analysis of the inherent vulnerability of risk, resulting in low accuracy of risk assessment. With a focus on the hazard factor, this study proposes a three-dimensional risk assessment approach based on grid management to carry out a personalized risk assessment of grid events. Through the grid division, the method can accurately identify the risk events of employees in any cell grid at a certain moment in the “grids-events-time” three-dimensional coordinate system, providing modeling support for personalized risk assessment. Then, a “probability-severity-vulnerability” three-dimensional risk assessment model is constructed. In this model, the probability is obtained by the induced intensity assignment function of the hazard factor, the vulnerability is obtained by the coupling strength assignment function of the hazard factor, and the severity of a single risk event is given a constant value. On this basis, the risk magnitude is determined by the “sum” algorithm of the three risk parameters. This methodology solves the problems of incomplete consideration of risk parameters and insufficient accuracy of quantitative analysis of risk magnitude in the previous risk assessment process and realizes the personalized and dynamic assessment of risk events of the train operation department. Finally, the methodology is applied to the risk event assessment of “the assistant watchman does not appear as required” at Huangyangcheng station of the Shenshuo Railway, and the evaluation results show that the risk magnitude of different elements in the same cell grid has an obvious individual difference, which fully embodies the advantages of grid risk assessment.
In the train operation department, the most important and dynamic factor is that the department employees are involved in all areas. Realizing the dynamic control of “key person, key event, and key period” to fundamentally curb employee inertia violation is a significant issue that needs to be solved on the railway site. The traditional “probability–severity” two-dimensional risk assessment model is carried out from the perspective of the system, ignoring the spatiotemporal risk characteristics of the individual, and a large amount of hazard factor data generated in the operation process is not applied in the risk assessment process. As a result, safety behavior risk practice lacks pertinence, accuracy, and individuation. This study proposes a safety behavior risk assessment model based on the grid management and hazard factor assignment function to improve the traditional two-dimensional risk matrix. By introducing spatial location variables, the method accurately locates and classifies the site staff and organizes the disorder and lack of associated risk data with regard to time and space. With a focus on the hazard factor, the induced intensity is proposed for the first time and considered as the input of probability calculation to innovate the traditional “probability–severity” risk matrix. Finally, the methodology is applied to the risk event assessment of “the assistant watchman doesn’t appear as required” scenario in the Huangyangcheng station of Shenshuo Railway, and the evaluation results realize the personalized evaluation of the risk event in different cell grids.
Employees are the most important and dynamic elements in the railway transportation system. How to achieve accurate control of inertial violation of “key person, key matter, key period”, and formulate more personalized risk response strategy is a thorny problem that faced by safety managers. The existing risk response usually takes control measures from the perspective of the system as a whole, ignoring the heterogeneity of risk, and the selection of response strategies only considers the target risks to be dealt with, ignoring the secondary risks that may occur in the process of risk response, or the residual risks formed by changing the existing risk, coupled with the lack of quantitative evaluation of risk response effect, resulting in poor risk response effect. By introducing the grid theory and taking the risk event of “the assistant watchman does not appear as required” at Huangyangcheng station of Shenshuo Railway as an example, this study constructs a grid response model of the assistant watchman risk events based on system dynamics. Through the grid division, the model accurately locates and classifies the assistant watchman on duty. Then, during the system dynamics simulation process, the hazard factor is regarded as a bridge, and the traditional virtual boundary of system simulation is transformed into accurate grid definition. By improving the response strategy of safety behavior risk event of the assistant watchman on duty in cell grid and using Vensim-PLE software for personalized simulation, the intervention of “the assistant watchman does not appear as required” risk event is transformed from qualitative analysis to dynamic quantitative mathematical model, so as to realize the personalized response simulation analysis of employees in the grid.