Inner Source (IS) is the use of open source software development practices and the establishment of an open source-like culture within organizations. The organization may still develop proprietary software but internally opens up its development. A steady stream of scientific literature and practitioner reports indicates the interest in this research area. However, the research area lacks a systematic assessment of known research work: No model exists that defines IS thoroughly. Various case studies provide insights into IS programs in the context of specific organizations but only few publications apply a broader perspective. To resolve this, we performed an extensive literature survey and analyzed 43 IS related publications plus additional background literature. Using qualitative data analysis methods, we developed a model of the elements that constitute IS. We present a classification framework for IS programs and projects and apply it to lay out a map of known IS endeavors. Further, we present qualitative models summarizing the benefits and challenges of IS adoption. The survey provides the first broad review of IS literature and systematic arrangement of IS research results.
The engineering of complex software systems is often the result of a highly collaborative effort. However, collaboration within a multinational enterprise has an overlooked legal implication when developers collaborate across national borders: It is taxable. In this article, we discuss the unsolved problem of taxing collaborative software engineering across borders. We (1) introduce the reader to the basic principle of international taxation, (2) identify three main challenges for taxing collaborative software engineering making it a software engineering problem, and (3) estimate the industrial significance of cross-border collaboration in modern software engineering by measuring cross-border code reviews at a multinational software company.
The internal reuse of software components owned by organizational units in different countries constitutes an implicit form of licensing that may be taxable under international regulations, making tax authorities an often overlooked stakeholder in software architecture. This study explores to what extent a deliberately minimal software architecture description can make implicit cross-border licensing visible and interpretable for tax experts. We define a deliberately minimal architecture viewpoint based on components, dependencies, ownership, and jurisdiction and construct a view for a large-scale industrial microservice software system comprising 2518 components and 16,533 dependencies. The resulting architecture description is evaluated in a judgment study with four experienced tax auditors and tax advisors using semi-structured interviews. The results show that the software architecture description provides a structured, evidence-based starting point for identifying cross-border reuse and supports tax audit discussions. However, experts report limitations, including mismatches between software engineering and legal notions of ownership, unclear jurisdictional assignments, and the perceived risk of interpreting dependency counts as indicators of economic value. These limitations persist despite detailed architectural data. We conclude that software architecture descriptions can expose structurally relevant reuse relationships but cannot, on their own, support the legally meaningful interpretations required for tax assessment, indicating a fundamental mismatch between architectural abstractions and taxation concepts.