Observations from the Dark Energy Spectroscopic Instrument Data Release 2 (DESI DR2) challenge the $\Lambda$ cold dark matter ($\Lambda$CDM) paradigm by suggesting that the equation-of-state parameter of dark energy evolves across $w = -1$, a phenomenon known as the quintom scenario. Motivated by this development, we present a staged review of quintom cosmology, including its theoretical foundations, observational supports, implications and possible extensions. We first trace the historical progression from Einstein’s static cosmological constant to modern dynamical dark energy, summarizing recent cosmological constraints that favor an evolving $w(z)$ with time. A key focus is the theoretical no-go theorem for dark energy, which shows that no single canonical field or perfect-fluid model can smoothly cross the $w = -1$ boundary. We then survey viable quintom constructions, including two-field models, single-scalar-field models with higher derivatives, modified-gravity frameworks, interacting dark energy and effective field theory approaches that unify these mechanisms. Possible interactions between quintom fields and ordinary matter, as well as their potential roles in yielding non-singular universe solutions, are discussed.
8 August 2024 in Monthly Notices of the Royal Astronomical Society
We employ Hubble data and Gaussian Processes in order to reconstruct the dynamical connection function in f(Q) cosmology beyond the coincident gauge. In particular, there exist three branches of connections that satisfy the torsionless and curvatureless conditions, parameterized by a new dynamical function γ. We express the redshift dependence of γ in terms of the H(z) function and the f(Q) form and parameters, and then we reconstruct it using 55 H(z) observation data. Firstly, we investigate the case where ordinary conservation law holds, and we reconstruct the f(Q) function, which is very well described by a quadratic correction on top of Symmetric Teleparallel Equivalent of General Relativity. Proceeding to the general case, we consider two of the most studied f(Q) models of the literature, namely the square-root and the exponential one. In both cases we reconstruct γ(z), and we show that according to AIC and BIC information criteria its inclusion is favoured compared to both ΛCDM paradigm, as well as to the same f(Q) models under the coincident gauge. This feature acts as an indication that f(Q) cosmology should be studied beyond the coincident gauge.
We investigate the realization of quintom scenario for dynamical dark energy within modified gravity theories that can efficiently fit the recent observational data sets. Starting from a general effective field theory formulation of dark energy in metric-affine geometry, we derive the background action in unitary gauge and we demonstrate how both f(T) and f(Q) gravity can naturally realize quintom behavior through appropriate forms and parameter choices. Additionally, using the Gaussian process reconstruction of the latest Dark Energy Spectroscopic Instrument DR2 baryon acoustic oscillation data combined with Type Ia supernovae and cosmic microwave background observations, we extract the reconstructed dark-energy equation-of-state parameter, showing that it exhibits quintom-type evolution, crossing the phantom divide from below. Moreover, through detailed parameter estimations and application of information criteria, we compare the model with the quadratic one and the ΛCDM model. Our results show that, due to its rich structure, modified gravity stands as one of the main candidates for the realization of the data-favored dynamical dark energy.
In this article we confront a class of f(Q) gravity models with observational data of galaxy–galaxy lensing. Specifically, we consider f(Q) gravity models containing a small quadratic correction when compared with general relativity (GR), and quantify this correction by a model parameter, α. To derive the observational constraints, we start by extracting spherically symmetric solutions, which correspond to deviations from the Schwarzschild solution that depends on the model parameters in a twofold way, i.e., a renormalized mass and a new term proportional to r−2. Then, we calculate the effective lensing potential, the deflection angle, the shear component, and the effective excess surface density profile. After that, we employ a group catalog and a shape catalog from the Sloan Digital Sky Survey Data Release 7 for the lens and source samples, respectively. Moreover, we handle the off-center radius as a free parameter and constrain it using a Markov Chain Monte Carlo method. Concerning the deviation parameter from GR we derive at the 1σ confidence level, and then compare the fitting efficiency with the standard Λ cold dark matter paradigm by applying the Akaike information criterion and Bayesian information criterion. Our results indicate that the f(Q) corrections alongside the off-center effect yield a scenario that is slightly favored.
1 August 2025 in Journal of Cosmology and Astroparticle Physics
In this article we use the latest cosmological observations, including SNe, BAO, CC and RSD, to reconstruct the cosmological evolution via Gaussian process regression. At the background level, we find consistency with quintom dynamics for different data combinations and categorize the characteristics of dark energy into three distinct types: negative-energy dark energy, late-dominated dark energy, and oscillating dark energy. Considering the effect of modified gravity on the growth of matter perturbations, the reconstruction results at the perturbative level indicate that only minor corrections to general relativity are required. Furthermore, we provide theoretical interpretation for these three different types of dynamical dark energy behavior, within the framework of modified gravity, scalar fields, and dark energy equation-of-state parametrizations. Finally, we show that all of these models can be unified within the framework of effective field theory.
We perform -body simulations for gravity using the ME-Gadget code, in order to investigate the structure formation process in detail for the first time. Focusing on the power-law model and considering the model parameter to be consistent within with all other cosmological data sets (such as type 1a supernovae, baryon acoustic oscillations, the cosmic microwave background, and cosmic chronometers), we show that there are clear observational differences between cosmology and gravity due to the modifications brought about by the latter in the evolution of the Hubble function and the effective Newton’s constant. We extract the matter density distribution, matter power spectrum, counts-in-cells, halo mass function, and excess surface density (ESD) around low-density positions (LDPs) at the present time. Concerning the matter power spectrum, we find a difference from that in the scenario, about of which is attributed to the different expansion and about to the effective gravitational constant. Additionally, we find a difference in the cells, which is significantly larger than the Poisson error, which may be distinguishable with weak-lensing reconstructed mass maps. Moreover, we show that there are different massive halos with masses , which may be distinguishable from statistical measurements of cluster number counting, and we find that the ESD around LDPs is mildly different. In conclusion, by highlighting possible smoking guns, we show that large-scale structure can indeed lead us to distinguish general relativity and cosmology from gravity.