This meta-analysis study, an Inquiry-based science education (IBSE), has been gaining increasing popularity as a strong pedagogy to develop students' problem-solving and critical thinking abilities in STEM (Science, Technology, Engineering, and Mathematics) education. This meta-analysis combines evidences from 40 various review articles and empirical studies that have appeared in prestigious research journals between 2016–2025 to analyse the impact of IBSE on the development of students' cognitive skills, i.e., their problem-solving ability and critical thinking skills. The research explores the relative quality of different kinds of inquiry, i.e., guided and open-ended inquiry, and identifies noteworthy determinants making IBST impactful in building such abilities. Research shows that IBST enhances significantly the critical thinking and problem-solving ability of the students with medium to large effect sizes at every level of education, from primary to tertiary. In addition, the research highlights teacher facilitation, planning of inquiry-based activities, and technology integration as the factors that help obtain the highest benefit in IBST. The student motivation and involvement also emerged as significant factors driving the success of IBST. These results hold insightful implications for education policy makers and educators to propel STEM education to new heights with the integration of inquiry-based approaches that stimulate higher-order skills in 21st-century.
North Sindh, Pakistan, is plagued by a number of socio-economic factors that confound the provision of quality education. Some of the most prominent issues include teacher shortages of qualified teachers and school facilities, among others. To offset such challenges, the Sindh Teachers Education and Development Authority (STEDA) and Provincial Institute of Teacher Education (PITE) have designed a series of Teacher Training Programs (TTPs). Their effect on Student Learning Outcomes (SLOs) remains to be adequately studied. The present study evaluates the effectiveness and quality of TTPs for Secondary School Teachers (SSTs) in North Sindh, highlighting important gaps such as the non-existence of assessment frameworks, contextual assessment, and feedback systems. The fact that investments have gone on unabated despite the absence of systematic evaluations has held back progress, resulting in flat outcomes. Using the case study approach, the research situates findings within the socio-cultural and institutional life of the region and offers meaningful information to policymakers and education leaders. It identifies the necessity for swift action to develop comprehensive appraisal and feedback systems to ensure continuous growth in teacher training and student achievement. Without such arrangements, long-term sustainability and effectiveness of TTPs are a matter of doubt, and education outcomes in North Sindh would likely continue to be unsatisfactory.
This action research study explores the dynamic relationship between Environmental Education and Lifelong Learning (EELL) as essential components in the pursuit of sustainable futures in the context of Sindh, Pakistan. As the global community grappling with pressing environmental challenges, it has become increasingly imperative to understand how learners acquire and apply environment related knowledge throughout their lives. Utilising the Participatory Action Research (PAR) method, this research develops a theoretical framework that sheds light on the complex interplay between EELL. The study identifies three key dimensions that characterize the relationship between EELL: (1) Personal Agency and Responsibility, (2) Adaptive Capacity, and (3) Social Engagement. The first dimension, Personal Agency and Responsibility, underscores the significant role of individual motivation and sense of responsibility in initiating and sustaining lifelong environmental learning. The second dimension, Adaptive Capacity, emphasizes the role of lifelong learning in building resilience and adaptability in the face of environmental changes. The third dimension, Social Engagement, underscores the significance of collaborative learning and community involvement in fostering environmental consciousness. This participatory action research offers valuable insights into the mechanisms through which EELL can jointly contribute to sustainable futures. It highlights the need for educational institutions, teachers, policymakers, intellectuals, and civil society members to promote a culture of lifelong learning and social engagement, empowering individuals to become active proponents of the environment. Eventually, in an era of unprecedented environmental crises, this study offers a useful framework for designing educational strategies and policies that can catalyse sustainable change at both individual and societal levels.
5 June 2026 in Australian Journal of Environmental Education
Global environmental crises, including climate change, biodiversity loss and resource depletion disproportionately affect communities in the Global South, where environmental vulnerability intersects with social and cultural inequalities. In rural North Sindh, Pakistan, these pressures shape everyday livelihoods and community practices through which environmental knowledge is transmitted across generations. Yet formal environmental education often overlooks these informal learning spaces. This study examines how family and community-based environmental and sustainability education cultivates action competence by integrating knowledge, motivation and action skills in a non-Western agrarian context. Guided by the Action Competence Approach as a theoretical and conceptual framework, the research employed a convergent parallel mixed-methods design within participatory action research. Data from 120 participants in Sukkur and Shikarpur were collected through surveys, interviews, focus groups and workshops. Findings show moderate-to-high action competence (M = 3.82/5), with strong environmental motivation and knowledge fostered through intergenerational storytelling, while action skills remain constrained by infrastructural and rural–urban disparities.
Purpose This study analyzed the relationship of STEAM Pedagogical practices with students STEAM competency development in higher education and how contextual constraints and institutional culture shape their implementation in Japan and Pakistan. Design/methodology/approach: A comparative concurrent mixed-methods design was adopted, integrating quantitative and qualitative data collected concurrently. Quantitative data captured using adopted survey questionnaire total of 293 (Pakistan 151 and Japan 142) students’ perceptions of STEAM practices and their competencies, while qualitative interviews with students and faculty (total of 10 students and 6 teachers; 5 students and 3 teachers from each country) provided insights into institutional and contextual factors influencing STEAM pedagogy. Quantitative analyses included nonparametric tests to compare perceptions across countries and hierarchical regression to assess the predictive and moderating roles of STEAM practices followed by thematic analysis of qualitative part of the study. Findings: The study found that STEAM pedagogical practices strongly predict student competency development, and this relationship is largely consistent across both national contexts. While differences in students’ perceptions of STEAM practices and competencies were observed, institutional and contextual factors, rather than national context per se, influence the translation of pedagogy into effective learning outcomes. Research limitations/implications: The study is limited to selected higher education institutions and convenience sampling, which may affect generalizability. Nonetheless, it highlights the importance of context-sensitive professional development and curriculum design for successful STEAM implementation. Practical implications: Findings offer guidance for educators and policymakers on enhancing student competencies through structured STEAM pedagogical practices while adapting to local institutional conditions. Originality/value: By integrating quantitative outcomes with qualitative insights, this study provides a cross-national perspective on STEAM pedagogy, emphasizing the interplay between instructional practices, institutional culture, and contextual constraints.
15 June 2026 in International Journal of Comparative Education and Development
Purpose: This paper aims to examine push and pull factors that affect elementary school dropout among girls in rural northern Sindh, Pakistan. The objective of producing contextualized insights to be used in shaping gender-sensitive educational policy and practice. The study views dropout with a mixed theoretical approach of push–pull theory and the gender inequality theory in order to gain a more theoretical insight to the structural and gendered problem of educational exclusion and discontinuation. Design/methodology/approach: The qualitative case study design was utilized and 10 out-of-school girls in one of the government elementary schools in northern Sindh were interviewed using semi-structured interviews and analyzed in detail. Thematic analysis was employed to analyze data based on push–pull conceptual categories and perspectives regarding gender inequality in order to define school-based, household and sociocultural factors that influenced dropout experience. Findings: The results indicate that the dropout of girls is the result of the compounding effect of the push factors at school(s) and the pull factors at home and in the community further increased by gender inequality. Some of the driving forces of female exclusion from schools are harsh behavior of teachers, poor quality of instruction and ineffective gender inclusive pedagogy, recurrent academic failure and withdrawal and emotional disengagement of students with schooling and education. The key pull factors include household socioeconomic status or poverty, long distance and safety issues, gendered household labor and caregiving, environmental shocks and disaster induced disruption and early marriage and transition into marital roles. Gendered social expectations exacerbate vulnerability in both fields and create a pattern of structural exclusion in education instead of a personal choice. Research limitations/implications: The study has a small qualitative sample with a single rural context; hence, it is hard to generalize the results. Nevertheless, it provides strong contextual insight into processes that contribute to girls' dropout and how theory-based qualitative research can be useful in the study of gendered educational inequality. It is suggested to use larger mixed-method and longitudinal designs in the future. Practical implications: The results indicate that multi-sectoral interventions such as gender-sensitive teacher training, remedial school-based support and safe transportation, disaster-resilient schooling, financial support of families in need and community-based interventions related to early marriage and gender-based domestic roles should be implemented. A combination of efforts in the education and social protection sectors as well as gender equity is essential to curb dropouts. Originality/value: This study contributes contextualized qualitative evidence from rural Sindh, a region with limited in-depth research on girls' educational exclusion and discontinuation. By integrating push–pull theory with gender inequality theory, it advances understanding of dropout as a gendered structural process, offering insights for policy and comparative education research in marginalized settings.