The EGFR gene is one of the most frequently mutated and/or amplified gene both in lung adenocarcinomas (LUAD) and in glioblastomas (GBMs). Although both tumor types depend on the mutation for growth, clinical benefit of EGFR tyrosine kinase inhibitors (TKIs) has only been observed in LUAD patients and, thus-far, not in GBM patients. Also in LUAD patients however, responses are restricted to specific EGFR mutations only and these ‘TKI-sensitive’ mutations hardly occur in GBMs. This argues for mutation-specific (as opposed to tumor-type specific) responses to EGFR-TKIs. We here discuss potential reasons for the differences in mutation spectrum and highlight recent evidence for specific functions of different EGFR mutations. These mutation-specific effects likely underlie the differential treatment response between LUAD and GBMs and provide new insights into how to target EGFR in GBM patients.
The gene encoding isocitrate dehydrogenase 1 (IDH1) is frequently mutated in several tumor types including gliomas. The most prevalent mutation in gliomas is a missense mutation leading to a substitution of arginine with histidine at the residue 132 (R132H). Wild type IDH1 catalyzes oxidative decarboxylation of isocitrate to α-ketoglutarate (α-KG) whereas mutant IDH1 converts α-KG into D2-hydroxyglutarate (D2HG). Unfortunately, there are few in vivo model systems for IDH-mutated tumors to study the effects of IDH1 mutations in tumor development. We have therefore created transgenic zebrafish lines that express various IDH1 mutants. IDH1 mutations (IDH1R132H, IDH1R132C and loss-of-function mutation IDH1G70D), IDH1wildtype or eGFP were cloned into constructs with several brain-specific promoters (Nestin, Gfap or Gata2). These constructs were injected into fertilized zebrafish eggs at the one-cell stage. In total more than ten transgenic zebrafish lines expressing various brain-specific IDH1 mutations were created. A significant increase in the level of D2HG was observed in all transgenic lines expressing IDH1R132C or IDH1R132H, but not in any of the lines expressing IDH1wildtype, IDH1G70D or eGFP. No differences in 5-hydroxymethyl cytosine and mature collagen IV levels were observed between wildtype and mutant IDH1 transgenic fish. To our surprise, we failed to identify any strong phenotype, despite increased levels of the oncometabolite D2HG. No tumors were observed, even when backcrossing with tp53-mutant fish which suggests that additional transforming events are required for tumor formation. Elevated D2HG levels could be lowered by treatment of the transgenic zebrafish with an inhibitor of mutant IDH1 activity. We have generated a transgenic zebrafish model system for mutations in IDH1 that can be used for functional analysis and drug screening. Our model systems help understand the biology of IDH1 mutations and its role in tumor formation.
Clinical responses to EGFR tyrosine kinase inhibitors are restricted only to tumors harboring specific activating mutations and even then, not all tyrosine kinase inhibitors provide clinical benefit. We here show that the addition of EGFR-TKIs results in a strong and rapid intracellular accumulation of the protein. However, this accumulation was observed only in the context of a combination of a TKI-sensitive mutation with a clinically effective TKI: TKI-insensitive mutations did not show this accumulation nor did clinically ineffective TKIs induce accumulation. All TKIs effectively inhibited EGFR phosphorylation and downstream pathway activation, irrespective of the mutation present in EGFR. The discrepancy between molecular activity of TKIs and their efficacy in patients therefore is mimicked by the mutation- and TKI-specificity of intracellular accumulation. Using this intracellular accumulation as assay, we were able to predict response to gefitinib in a panel of cell-lines (harboring different EGFR mutations) and predicted clinical benefit to EGFR TKIs on a cohort of unselected pulmonary adenocarcinoma patients (hazard ratio 0.21, P=0.0004). Even in patients harboring rare mutations with unknown TKI-sensitivity, intracellular accumulation was predictive of the clinical response. The intracellular accumulation depended on a continued presence of TKI indicating that TKIs exert a continued effect on the protein even after its dephosphorylation. It is therefore possible that accumulation is caused by conformational changes induced by both the mutation and the TKI and this change induces a block in intracellular trafficking. Interestingly, intracellular accumulation was observed independent of the genetic background of the cell, indicating that accumulation is almost entirely dictated by the combination of mutation and TKI. Our results therefore suggest that TKI-sensitivity is tumor-type independent.