Beth Hardie

Dr. Beth Hardie

orcid

Research Focus & Metrics

Academic Career Length

15Years (2012-Present)

(Calculated once Scilit publication data is synced: current year − year of first publication + 1)

Representative Publications

View All Publications
14 January 2018 in European Journal of Criminology
Verified
Journal Article
Open access
PWPer-Olof H Wikström
Per-Olof H Wikström
RMRichard P Mann
Richard P Mann
BHBeth Hardie
Beth Hardie
The overall purpose of this study is to contribute to bridging the gap between people- and place-oriented approaches in the study of crime causation. To achieve this we will explore some core hypotheses derived from Situational Action Theory about what makes young people crime prone and makes places criminogenic, and about the interaction between crime propensity and criminogenic exposure predicting crime events. We will also calculate the expected reduction in aggregate levels of crime that will occur as a result of successful interventions targeting crime propensity and criminogenic exposure. To test the hypotheses we will utilize a unique set of space–time budget, small area community survey, land-use and interviewer-led questionnaire data from the prospective longitudinal Peterborough Adolescent and Young Adult Development Study (PADS+) and an artificial neural network approach to modelling. The results show that people’s crime propensity (based on their personal morals and abilities to exercise self-control) has the bulk of predictive power, but also that including criminogenic exposure (being unsupervised with peers and engaged in unstructured activities in residential areas of poor collective efficacy or commercial centres) demonstrates a substantial increase in predictive power (in addition to crime propensity). Moreover, the results show that the probability of crime is strongest when a crime-prone person is in a criminogenic setting and, crucially, that the higher a person’s crime propensity the more vulnerable he or she is to influences of criminogenic exposure. Finally, the findings suggest that a reduction in people’s crime propensity has a much bigger impact on their crime involvement than a reduction in their exposure to criminogenic settings.

12 February 2016 in Deviant Behavior
Verified
Journal Article
Closed access
HHHelmut Hirtenlehner
Helmut Hirtenlehner
BHBeth Hardie
Beth Hardie
Classic self-control theory and the pure deterrence argument have both been recently challenged by integrative theory and appropriate empirical evidence suggesting that controls are only conditionally relevant to action. Situational Action Theory (SAT) provides a fertile framework within which to study the effectiveness of controls. Specifically, SAT’s principle of the conditional relevance of controls states that controls only influence behavior when a person is forced to deliberate over action alternatives because of conflict between his/her own moral rules and those of the setting. That the moral filter does not preclude crime from the action alternatives perceived by an individual can be due to weak personal moral norms or exposure to a crime-conducive moral context. In particular, SAT states that (1) deterrence (external control) only becomes relevant to deliberations when personal morality is weak and (2) the process of self-control (internal control) only becomes relevant to deliberations when an individual is exposed to criminogenic moral contexts. Both these hypotheses are tested with a large-scale Austrian student survey dedicated to the explanation of adolescent shoplifting. The results provide firm support for these key propositions of SAT.

1 January 2012
Verified
Book Chapter
Closed access
PWPer-Olof H. Wikström
Per-Olof H. Wikström
KTKyle Treiber
Kyle Treiber
BHBeth Hardie
Beth Hardie

8 October 2019 in Deviant Behavior
Verified
Journal Article
Closed access
BHBeth Hardie
Beth Hardie
Parental monitoring is often shown to have a negative relationship with crime involvement. However, research often ignores both the mechanism by which these relationships occur and the conditions under which they might (and might not) be found. Building on the interactional hypotheses of Situational Action Theory (SAT) and the parental monitoring definitions provided by a new model of Goal-Directed Parental Action (GDPA), this paper assesses evidence of the role of the presence or absence of guardians, adolescent-perceived parental knowledge and personal crime propensity in explaining why a crime does or doesn’t occur in a particular situation. To test these new hypotheses, this paper uses specialist data (including innovative Space-Time Budget data) from the Peterborough Adolescent and Young Adult Development Study (PADS+) and employs multiple methods to assess both statistical interaction (dependence) and situational interaction (convergence). Findings provide evidence for interaction between key personal characteristics (specifically, generalized law relevant morality and ability to exercise self control) and features of environments (in this study, aspects of parental monitoring) in the perception-choice process that is proposed by SAT to explain action, including acts of crime. They suggest that despite high correlations with crime in the literature, monitoring doesn’t always matter because many crime averse young people do not offend anyway. Furthermore, in an entirely new finding, generalized perceived parental knowledge of the circumstances of activity (psychological presence) results in a lower rate of crime among crime prone adolescents when they are unsupervised.

17 January 2025 in European Journal of Criminology
Verified
Journal Article
Open access
BHBeth Hardie
Beth Hardie
CRChae Rose
Chae Rose
Situational Action Theory's (SAT) situational model is being increasingly applied to study rule-breaking behaviours. Given this rapidly growing interest, it is timely to review the state of empirical support for the model and identify conceptual and methodological challenges in order to guide future studies in more appropriate tests of the model. This paper systematically reviews 37 quantitative tests of SAT's situational model that were published during the 5 years from 2016 to 2020 to formulate and then answer the following research questions: (1) What samples and offences have been studied to investigate the situational propositions put forward by SAT, and what are the most needed kinds of studies and replications? (2) What is the state of empirical support for SAT's situational model? (3) What are the challenges and what improvements are required for future tests of SAT's situational model? and (4) What clarifications and refinements are a theoretical priority? Overall findings of the review highlight the utility of SAT's situational model in investigating a diversity of rule-breaking behaviours across a range of ages and countries. However, the review also makes clear that when reviewed as a whole, this literature encounters methodological pitfalls and theoretical imprecision. These limitations must be addressed as empirical tests of SAT's complex situational model become increasingly nuanced and highly specified. Thus, building on the findings of the systematic review, the paper explores these complex limitations and specifies the theoretical and methodological refinements required to advance the study of person-environment interaction in acts of rule-breaking.

1 April 2021 in New Ideas in Psychology
Verified
Journal Article
Closed access
BHBeth Hardie
Beth Hardie