The psychoanalytic movement is experiencing a serious crisis: its scientific consensus, social standing, and impact on practice in mental health have all been steadily declining over the last decades. This unfortunate process has been variously explained in terms of prevailing hedonistic social values, the political influence of drug companies, and cuts in health-related expenditures. Following a suggestion by Garza Guerrero, we rather believe that the sources of the contemporary crisis in psychoanalysis are to be searched for within its own development and current social and cultural life. Specifically, we think psychoanalysis has failed to bring the revolutionary contribution of interpersonal and intersubjective paradigms to its fuller consequences. Here, we review five core dimensions in which such failure is particularly apparent: (1) an unwitting reliance on the medical model of mental illness; (2) an ontological, concrete understanding of unconscious processes; (3) a manifest failure to fully appreciate the role of extratransference relationships in the patient’s life; (4) a naive and idealized view of the psychoanalyst’s person and role; and (5) a marginal awareness of the impact of group-level unconscious phenomena on the social life of psychoanalytic institutions.
1 March 2005 in The European Journal of Psychiatry
The position within the Oedipal phantasy has become a basic organizer in social conflicts of XXI century society. This development is particularly apparent in the current confrontation between the Catholic clergy and anticlerical activists. Consistently with Sigmund Freud’s conceptualization of the negative oedipal constellation, the two institutionalized groups share a basic unconscious feature: an incomplete cleavage of the pre-Oedipal relationship to the mother object. At puberty, a persistent regressive tie to the mother hinders the investment of age-appropriate female partners and maintains the adolescent within the mother’s embrace. Two options are available than in order to keep at bay father’s control and interpersonal power. The submission to Super-ego values and the repression of sexual drives warrants the father’s complacency and makes room for an ascetic life. On the other hand, a more eroticized identification with mother may bestow the adolescent a seductive interpersonal power over father’s representatives. Material from an analytic case allows the author to illuminate the severely traumatic primal scene experiences often underlying a passive Oedipal constellation. In this perspective, the current heated confrontation between the Church and anticlerical activists may be understood in terms of an unconscious fantasy where primal scene anxieties are reciprocally projected onto the political opponents.