Introduction: The WHO has set a 2030 target to raise effective cataract surgical coverage (eCSC) by 30 percentage points in every country, requiring gains in surgical access and quality. Despite this mandate, evidence on how low- and middle-income health systems are implementing eCSC remains limited. Methods: We conducted a qualitative comparative case study in Kenya and Nepal. 20 interviews were held with senior stakeholders from government, non-governmental organisations, academic institutions and clinical networks. Transcripts were thematically analysed using the consolidated framework for implementation research, adapted into a growing systems framework to capture national-level dynamics. Results: Implementation unfolds within the inherent structures of each cataract system rather than through centrally imposed directives. In Kenya, cataract services operate within devolved county structures supported by non-governmental organization (NGO) partnerships and national technical coordination. In Nepal, vertically organised NGO networks deliver care through a hub-and-spoke outreach model with limited government oversight. Both systems incorporate context-specific adaptations to overcome barriers in access and postoperative quality. Public–private partnerships expand reach but are weakened by fragmented financing, reliance on donors and high out-of-pocket costs. Outcome monitoring is sporadic and seldom informs planning, limiting system-wide learning. Conclusion: The eCSC target prompts change less by prescribing reform than by revealing the features that enable or constrain implementation. Sustained progress will require embedding outcome monitoring within routine information systems, strengthening public stewardship of mixed provider networks, mobilising domestic financing and designing services attuned to geographic and sociocultural realities.
25 September 2024 in American Journal of Ophthalmology
Global eye health is increasingly recognized as integral to achieving universal health coverage (UHC), with equity, access, and service integration serving as key indicators of system performance. Israel provides a distinctive case study, having established UHC through the 1994 National Health Insurance Law, which guarantees essential services to all residents. This review assesses Israel’s eye care system through a public and global health lens, applying the WHO health system building blocks to examine its organization, strengths, and persistent challenges. Israel benefits from strong integration of eye care within its universal framework, a high density of specialists, and wide availability of advanced services; yet inequities remain, particularly for lower-income and peripheral populations who face financial and geographic barriers to advanced treatment and consistent follow-up. Priority reforms include strengthening primary and community-based services, redistributing the workforce, and adopting nationally representative data and global indicators such as effective cataract surgical coverage (eCSC). Israel’s experience highlights both the potential and limits of universalism, offering lessons for countries seeking to integrate eye health into broader health planning as part of the global drive toward UHC.
3 August 2024 in Canadian Journal of Ophthalmology