HIV-2 infection results in progressive CD4 lymphopenia and death if untreated. The course of HIV-2 infection is more indolent than HIV-1, and the viral and immune mechanisms responsible for this slower pathogenesis are incompletely understood. Persistent inflammation with elevations in cellular and soluble markers of immune activation is a characteristic feature of HIV-2 infection and has been reported to be related to levels of HIV-infected cells in peripheral blood. Here we report an individual with HIV-2 who had persistently elevated levels of activated CD8 lymphocyte subsets that were significantly higher than those quantified in a set of controls without HIV matched for age, sex, and race. Despite elevated levels of immune activation, no detectable HIV-2 RNA or proviral DNA was present in blood. Without undergoing antiretroviral therapy, longitudinal analysis revealed this sustained immune activation was not associated with a progressive CD4 lymphopenia or evidence of disease complications. The presence of strong immune responses without detectable levels of HIV-2 nucleic acid complicates diagnostic testing for HIV-2, and highlights gaps in our understanding of HIV-2 pathogenesis.