NOTCH3 is a highly conserved transmembrane receptor implicated in CADASIL, a hereditary small-vessel disease caused predominantly by mutations affecting its extracellular EGF-like repeats. The mechanisms by which these muta-tions cause pathology remain incompletely understood. We present the first large-scale comparative bioinformatics and molecular dynamics (MD) analysis of NOTCH3 across 113 mammalian species, revealing three novel findings: (i) near-complete conservation of all 204 cysteine residues, with the only exception being eight naturally occurring cysteine substitutions in jaguar EGFr13–15; (ii) a unique deletion within the regulatory region of Brandt’s bat that may increase protease accessibility and alter receptor signaling; and (iii) a rare human NOTCH3-X1 isoform, absent from most mam-mals but shared with select primates, a bat, and elephants, involving a cysteine-depleting deletion spanning EGFr20–22. These naturally occurring exceptions demonstrate that alterations predicted to be deleterious under current pathogenic-ity models can be tolerated in specific evolutionary contexts. Together, these findings provide new insights into the structure–function relationships of NOTCH3, refine the interpretation of CADASIL-associated variants, and identify testable targets for future experimental studies. Our study highlights the power of comparative bioinformatics to uncover previously unrecognized functional features in disease-associated mammalian proteins.