Objective: To challenge the longstanding assumption that the sonographic Shred Sign and the Fractal Sign are synonymous and to redefine their diagnostic relationship in peripheral lung disease. Methods and Study Design: This prospective observational study analysed 700 consecutive comprehensive lung ultrasound examinations obtained from hospitalized patients. All patients underwent chest computed tomography (CT) and lung ultrasound as part of the routine diagnostic evaluation. Final diagnoses were established according to current international disease-specific guidelines by integrating clinical findings, laboratory investigations, CT imaging, microbiological studies, bronchoscopy, histopathology, and clinical follow-up, where appropriate. Morphological analysis was subsequently performed on the lung ultrasound examinations after diagnostic confirmation. Setting: Single tertiary university pulmonary referral centre. Participants: Seven hundred consecutive patients undergoing comprehensive lung ultrasound for peripheral lung disease. Primary outcome measure: Comparative assessment of the morphological characteristics of the Shred Sign across confirmed pulmonary diseases, focusing on boundary geometry, internal echotexture, air bronchogram dynamics, and airway patency. Secondary outcome measure: Identification and characterization of the True Fractal Sign, Non-Fractal Shred Sign, and Fractal Mimicry based on the combined morphological profile. Results: Among 700 examinations, 446 demonstrated an irregular pleural–parenchymal interface (Shred Sign). Of these, 127 exhibited fractal-like morphology; 126 fulfilled the criteria for a True Fractal Sign, whereas one lung cancer represented Fractal Mimicry. The remaining 319 cases were classified as Non-Fractal Shred Signs. True Fractal Signs were identified only in a subset of acute pneumonias, whereas Non-Fractal Shred Signs occurred both in acute pneumonias and in pulmonary infarction, tuberculosis, bronchiectasis, lung cancer, and other structural lung diseases. These findings demonstrate that the Shred Sign and the True Fractal Sign are distinct sonographic entities rather than synonymous findings. Conclusions: The Shred Sign is a broad descriptive sonographic pattern rather than a specific diagnostic entity. The True Fractal Sign represents a distinct geometric subtype associated with preservation of the alveolar branching architecture during acute exudative pneumonia. Based on these findings, we propose a novel four-pillar diagnostic tetrad integrating boundary geometry, internal shade, dynamic air bronchograms, and airway patency to differentiate True Fractal Sign, Non-Fractal Shred Sign, and Fractal Mimicry. This morphology-based framework may improve the diagnostic specificity of bedside lung ultrasound. The observation that many acute pneumonias lack a True Fractal Sign generates the hypothesis that preservation of fractal architecture depends on the integrity of the underlying lung structure and the stage of disease, warranting prospective validation.