Inspired by Lehmer’s conjecture on the non-vanishing of the Ramanujan $$\tau $$ -function, one may ask whether an odd integer $$\alpha $$ can be equal to $$\tau (n)$$ or any coefficient of a newform f(z). Balakrishnan, Craig, Ono and Tsai used the theory of Lucas sequences and Diophantine analysis to characterize non-admissible values of newforms of even weight $$k\ge 4$$ . We use these methods for weight 2 and 3 newforms and apply our results to L-functions of modular elliptic curves and certain K3 surfaces with Picard number $$\ge 19$$ . In particular, for the complete list of weight 3 newforms $$f_\lambda (z)=\sum a_\lambda (n)q^n$$ that are $$\eta $$ -products, and for $$N_\lambda $$ the conductor of some elliptic curve $$E_\lambda $$ , we show that if $$|a_\lambda (n)|<100$$ is odd with $$n>1$$ and $$(n,2N_\lambda )=1$$ , then $$\begin{aligned} a_\lambda (n) \in&\{-5,9,\pm 11,25, \pm 41, \pm 43, -45,\pm 47,49, \pm 53,55, \pm 59, \pm 61,\\&\pm 67, -69,\pm 71,\pm 73,75, \pm 79,\pm 81, \pm 83, \pm 89,\pm 93 \pm 97, 99\}. \end{aligned}$$ Assuming the Generalized Riemann Hypothesis, we can rule out a few more possibilities leaving $$\begin{aligned} a_\lambda (n) \in \{-5,9,\pm 11,25,-45,49,55,-69,75,\pm 81,\pm 93, 99\}. \end{aligned}$$