Accurately characterizing the utilization state of shale oil reservoirs is important for understanding post-development hydrocarbon occurrence and remaining oil potential. This study investigated mudstone–shale reservoirs from the Chang 63 to Chang 73 intervals of Well Y1 in the Ordos Basin, with Chang 72 representing the principal fractured target. A total of 27 samples were analyzed by Rock-Eval pyrolysis, 24 by saturated-hydrocarbon GC–MS, and 22 by pore-structure characterization. These data were integrated with logging-interpreted hydrocarbon saturation and statistical analyses to evaluate development-associated geochemical responses. Relative to Chang 73, Chang 72 exhibits a distinct molecular-compositional pattern, characterized by an increase in the mean Pr/nC17 ratio from 0.190 to 0.320 and a decrease in the mean ΣC20−/ΣC21+ ratio from 2.477 to 1.416, together with corresponding variations in terpane and sterane assemblages. These characteristics are consistent with selective mobilization and redistribution of hydrocarbon components during development. Pyrolysis parameters, logging-interpreted saturation, and sealed-core comparisons are further consistent with a preferential development response in Chang 72 while indicating that a substantial residual oil-bearing basis was retained. Its relatively large macropore and total pore volumes and low D2 value provide favorable pore-scale conditions for the potential mobility of movable oil, whereas the more complex smaller-pore system favors retention of less-mobile hydrocarbons. The results clarify the geochemical response characteristics and pore-scale controls of shale-oil utilization in the Chang 7 Member, providing geochemical constraints on the post-development utilization state and remaining-oil potential. Overall, the combined evidence supports a qualitative interpretation that Chang 72 underwent preferential and selective utilization while retaining a substantial residual oil-bearing basis.