Background: Mental wellbeing is inversely associated with future anxiety, but it remains uncertain whether moral reference systems condition the strength of this association. This study examined religious moral orientation (RMO) and secular moral orientation (SMO) as potential moderators. Methods: A convenience sample of 400 university students in Türkiye completed self-report measures of mental wellbeing, future anxiety, RMO, and SMO. Analyses involving future anxiety used 391 complete cases. RMO and SMO were scored as distinct subscales and were not summed. Separate moderated regressions constituted the primary analyses; bootstrap, HC3-robust, joint-model, and covariate-adjusted estimates were examined as sensitivity analyses. Results: Higher mental wellbeing was associated with lower future anxiety. The mental wellbeing × RMO interaction was negative under normal-theory estimation ( p = 0.003), but the percentile-bootstrap 95% confidence interval included zero and the separate-model HC3 result was just above the conventional threshold ( p = 0.0503). The mental wellbeing × SMO interaction was not significant in the primary model ( p = 0.078). Neither the unstandardized ( p = 0.877) nor fully standardized ( p = 0.553) joint-model contrast indicated that the interaction coefficients differed. Conclusion: The inverse association between mental wellbeing and future anxiety may vary with moral orientation, but evidence for RMO as a moderator was estimation-sensitive and the data did not establish distinct moderating effects for RMO and SMO. The findings are preliminary because the design was cross-sectional, the sample came from one university, and the interaction effects were small.