The goal of this study was to examine how the use of a new instructional model is related to changes in middle school students’ engineering identity. The intent of this instructional model, which is called argument-driven engineering (ADE), is to give students opportunities to design and critique solutions to meaningful problems using the core ideas and practices of science and engineering. The model also reflects current recommendations found in the literature for supporting the development or maintenance of engineering identity. This study took place in the context of an eighth-grade science classroom in order to explore how middle school students’ engineering identities change over time as they become more familiar with engineering core ideas and practices. One hundred students participated in this study. These students completed three design tasks during the school year that were created using the ADE instructional model. These students also completed a survey that was designed to measure two important aspects of an engineering identity (recognition and interest) at three different time points. The results of a hierarchical linear modeling analysis suggest that students’ ideas about how they view themselves and others view them in terms of engineering did not change over time and their reported interest decreased from one survey to the next. The difficulty of the design tasks and the ways teachers enacted the instructional model are proposed as potential explanations for this counterintuitive finding.
28 August 2022 in International Journal of Science Education
We examine how a unique professional learning experience for teachers, which consists of an opportunity to (a) co-design a new instructional model intended to give students opportunities to participate in scientific argumentation, (b) develop instructional materials based on the new model, and then (c) use the materials inside their classrooms, is related to changes in teacher beliefs and teaching practices over time. These cases suggest participation in this type of professional learning experience altered these teachers’ beliefs and these changes were guided by their experiences inside the classroom when teaching lessons with these new instruction materials. Our findings indicate that teacher reflection on their instructional decisions and the nature of student activity during lessons using the materials had a great influence on the beliefs and practices of these teachers. The implications of this finding suggest that an opportunity to develop instructional materials during a professional learning experience can foster a context for teachers to think about teaching and learning in new ways but any real change in teacher thinking and practices requires teachers to (a) use the materials they develop and then (b) problematise their current instructional practices.
2 January 2022 in International Journal of Science Education
Calls for engineering integration in pre-collegiate science courses are being made across the globe. The success of such efforts depends heavily on science teachers changing their instructional practices to include engineering. We conjecture when a science teacher chooses to make instructional change, including a change to integrate engineering practices and core ideas into science, the change helps them satisfy one or more of their goals. The purpose of this study is to present an exploratory case study of the goals a group of teachers satisfied when choosing to integrate engineering design into science classes. The primary data source is 31 semi-structured interviews while the teachers were engaged in creating and implementing four design challenges integrating engineering and science. Our findings show the teachers satisfied three types of goals through the use of the integrated engineering learning experiences: (a) habits of mind goals, such as students learning critical thinking; (b) preparation for the future goals, such as preparing students for future courses; and, (c) science education goals, such as students learning state science standards. We discuss these findings in relationship to the literature on instructional change and provide implications for both research and teacher education.
Science and engineering practices are intended to engage students authentically in the work that scientists and engineers do in order to provide opportunities for meaningful engagement in disciplinary work, including design-based learning. Meaningful engagement, particularly for sensemaking purposes, requires a shift in who is leading the classroom community’s intellectual work, from the teacher to the students. When students are positioned with the intellectual responsibility of producing and evaluating ideas, there is potential for them to act with epistemic agency. Enacting epistemic agency involves socially negotiated framing and power dynamics. The purpose of this study is to determine the ways in which gendered power dynamics influence the negotiation of epistemic agency in a design-based learning context. Using a qualitative case study methodology, student negotiations of epistemic and positional framing from a mixed-gender group were observed. Transcripts from their discourse during two design challenges were mapped, and focal group interviews were holistically analyzed to understand students’ perceptions and navigation of epistemic and positional framings in a design-based learning context and to understand how power dynamics influence these negotiations. Students understood the epistemic goals of the design challenges to involve designing solutions to real-world problems. During the first challenge, the group distributed positions of epistemic authority among the members. However, the group experienced a change in composition, resulting in changed power dynamics and epistemic oppression. These findings have implications regarding the critical impact that classroom culture and interactional practices might have on students’ epistemic agency, especially considering their multiple identity markers.
Frameworks of core practice in science teaching name practices either generally enough to span the disciplinary practices of the field or specifically toward explanation and modeling, leaving open what teaching requires when the practice at hand is argument. I elaborate those frameworks by specifying seven foundational teaching practices for argumentation that are scientific in nature. The practices are creating and leveraging instances of uncertainty, framing joint enterprise, making argumentation public, introducing and mediating argumentation tools, establishing and refining shared criteria for what counts as an acceptable argument, developing and maintaining norms for critique and disagreement, and noticing and responding to student reasoning and needs. What distinguishes them is the shift from building an account of a phenomenon to adjudicating among competing accounts, which asks a class to work out what counts as adequate reasoning rather than only to apply standards it has been given. Because the sciences reason in more than one style, and each carries its own epistemic criteria, the criteria a class develops are style-dependent rather than general. Equity is constitutive of the practices rather than a parallel commitment. I close by considering enactment under institutional constraint and implications for teacher educators, researchers, and curriculum designers.