Interventions for attention-deficit/hyperactivity disorder (ADHD) include positive behavior supports (e.g., parent training, school-based contingency management, behavioral peer interventions), training interventions (e.g., organizational skills training, social skills training, etc.), and other interventions (e.g., academic accommodations/modifications, self-monitoring). There is a need to conduct a comprehensive meta-analysis of psychosocial treatments for ADHD given discrepancies between meta-analyses. The present meta-analysis reports the results of between-group studies that compared a psychosocial treatment to a control condition from 1968 to 2016. In total, 226 studies were identified that met inclusion criteria. Results of the meta-analysis were organized by treatment type, rater, and domain of outcome assessed. Results indicated considerable variability across these parameters, with the strongest effects for proximal outcomes of behavioral parent training (improvements in parenting behaviors yielded a standardized mean difference of 0.70) and improvements in child behavior following implementation of behavioral school intervention (standardized mean difference of 0.66 and 0.72 for teacher ratings of ADHD symptoms and impairment, respectively). Other interventions were not extensively studied as stand-alone approaches. Results are discussed in light of current support for the use of psychosocial interventions for individuals with ADHD.
1 May 2022 in Journal of Consulting and Clinical Psychology
Evaluate whether stimulant medication improves acquisition of academic material in children with ADHD receiving small-group, content-area instruction in a classroom setting. Participants were 173 children between the ages of 7 and 12 (77% male, 86% Hispanic) who met DSM −5 criteria for ADHD and were participating in a therapeutic summer camp. The design was a triple-masked, within-subject, AB/BA crossover trial. Children completed two consecutive phases of daily, 25-minute instruction in both (a) subject-area content (science, social studies) and (b) vocabulary. Each phase was a standard instructional unit lasting for 3 weeks. Teachers and aides taught the material to small groups in a summer classroom setting. Each child was randomized to be medicated with daily osmotic-release oral system methylphenidate (OROS-MPH) during either the first or second of the instructional phases, receiving placebo during the other. Medication had large, salutary, statistically significant effects on children’s academic seatwork productivity and classroom behavior on every single day of the instructional period. However, there was no detectable effect of medication on learning the material taught during instruction: children learned the same amount of subject-area and vocabulary content whether they were taking OROS-MPH or placebo during the instructional period. Acute effects of OROS-MPH on daily academic seatwork productivity and classroom behavior did not translate into improved learning of new academic material taught via small-group, evidence-based instruction.
8 July 2022 in Research on Child and Adolescent Psychopathology
Evidence-based treatments for childhood attention-deficit/hyperactivity disorder (ADHD) include behavioral treatment and psychostimulants, preferably in combination. Research on the treatment of ADHD underscores a gap in the literature regarding the optimal sequencing of treatments (Pelham, Jr. & Altszuler, 2020). Emerging evidence supports starting with behavioral treatment before psychostimulants, though the mechanisms of this sequencing effect are not entirely understood. This study explores one plausible mechanism-that psychostimulants reduce behaviors targeted by behavioral treatment, thereby reducing opportunities for children to learn and practice self-regulation skills. The article reports post hoc findings from a triple-masked, AB/BA crossover study, conducted in the Summer Treatment Program (STP). Two-hundred forty-eight children diagnosed with ADHD; 77% male; 85% Hispanic) were randomized to receive either (a) intensive behavior therapy plus medication ("COMB") or (b) intensive behavior therapy plus placebo ("BT") for 3 weeks, then crossed over to the other condition for 3 weeks. Behavior in recreational settings was systematically recorded and analyzed as a function of medication status and order of treatments. We found evidence that initial medication reduced the efficacy of subsequent behavior therapy. That is, children exhibited significantly more misbehaviors when unmedicated if they started with combined treatment, then had medication withdrawn, than if they started with behavior therapy alone. These findings suggest that starting with a combined treatment approach had an unintended adverse impact on children's behavioral functioning when medication was withdrawn. The results support current clinical recommendations, which are to start treatment of ADHD with behavior therapy alone and to add medication as necessary.