Fundamental questions in value sensitive design include whether and how high-tech products/artefacts could embody values and ethical ideals, and how plural and incommensurable values of ethical and social importance could be chosen rationally and objectively at a collective level. By using a humanitarian cargo drone study as a starting point, this paper tackles the challenges that VSD’s lack of commitment to a specific ethical theory generates in practical applications. Besides, it highlights how mainstream ethical approaches usually related to VSD are incapable of solving main ethical dilemmas raised bytechnological design for well-beingin democratic settings. Accordingly, it is argued that VSD’s ethical-democratic import would substantially be enhanced by the espousal of aprocedural ethicsstance and thedeliberativeapproach to value and welfare entailed by Amartya Sen’s capability approach. Differently from rival ethical–political theories, its normative and meta-ethical foundations better handle human diversity, value-goal pluralism, conflicting vested interests as well as the epistemic-moral disagreements typical of contemporary complex democracies. Particularly, Sen’s capability approach procedural-deliberative tenets result in an “objective-impartial” choice procedure selecting a “hierarchy” of plural incommensurable values and rational goals thus, suitable to validate an applied science such as welfare-oriented technological design in concrete social environments. Conclusions suggest that refining VSD with a capability-based procedural approach to ethics fosters the concern for democracy and social justice while preserving vital scientific-technical standards. Major advantages are at an applied level to delivering ethically and socially justified, but yet highly functional technologies and high-tech products/artefacts.
Value Sensitive Design (VSD) is an interdisciplinary approach to technological development that systematically incorporates ethical considerations and social impacts as design inputs. Here, the VSD methodology is described, and elements of VSD are applied with a technological focus to analyze an existing prototype humanitarian cargo drone. Then, a new proposed drone design that better supports the values of human welfare (physical, psychological, and material welfare), and environmental sustainability is developed. The new drone is a high-speed fixed-wing drone which uses internal combustion engines and drops its payload via parachute to minimize transportation time and maximize patient physical welfare. It uses lower levels of automation such as manual flight monitoring to increase reliability and safety (physical welfare), and support the local workforce (material welfare). The drone uses much less energy than the technology it replaces, and is therefore much more environmentally friendly, supporting environmental sustainability. This work contributes by being the first to apply VSD methods to the technological development of a specific drone platform, and by demonstrating how drone engineers can use VSD to develop ”ethical” drones.
We review methods for economic evaluation recently developed in health economics by focusing on the epistemic and non-epistemic values they embody. The emphasis is on insights into valuing health, health states or resource management, against conventional approaches using QALY and DALY. The main hypothesis is that economic evaluation and related allocations of economic resources for health and healthcare could be improved by jointly adopting robust methods and broader normative theories within contemporary liberal-egalitarianism. Here, Amartya Sen’s Capability Approach (CA), which shifts attention away from individuals’ preferences for different health, healthcare options and utility maximisation, thereby provide more accurate evaluations of people’s states of health and their objective needs. This combination establishes a beneficial interplay between crucial epistemic values (objectivity-impartiality, consistency, evidence) and non-epistemic values (fairness-equity, redistributive justice). Thus, it is expected to amend methods and normative concepts for economic evaluations of public health in a genuine ‘extra-welfarist’ perspective.
The paper explores patterns of skilled labour mobility from the Southern eurozone to the metropolitan area of Copenhagen by means of a qualitative micro-study. The key hypothesis is that in/outflows may not only be a consequence of the present economic crisis but may also rely on the deep-rooted, democratic-socio-cultural aspects or dissimilar policy choices of sending/hosting countries. These same aspects are expected to influence return/circular migration. In contrast to mainstream theories of international migration, this viewpoint is supported by findings which illustrate how non-economic factors can be also crucial and why enhancing beneficial return/circular migration in the Southern eurozone can be incompatible with the application of austerity.
Citizen science is the new mantra both in academic circles and the public discourse. While the citizen science ideal is conceptually broad, If and how it can be realized in fields often depicted as value free/value neutral—such as applied AI—is controversial. The practical challenges in generating ethical AI encapsulating the citizen science ideal are addressed by targeting scientific practices underlying the participatory design of an AI-based tracking app aimed at enhancing the safety and wellbeing of vulnerable citizens with dementia of a Danish municipality through the engagement of the local community. The focus is on the process of social value construction and its citizen science rationale: how design values have been debated, traded-off, and selected via participatory-deliberative methods and by engaging experts and non-expert stakeholders as citizen scientists. An emphasis is on the import of dialogic interaction for negotiating values in open conversations within diverse groups of interest. Deliberative procedures are beneficial to produce ethical AI embodying vital citizen science desiderata since users’/citizens' values, needs, and expectations are fulfilled while technical-efficiency standards are also met. The result is a public methodology for designing ethical AI that better expresses the true spirit of citizen science in liberal democracies (value-laden, pluralistic, inter-disciplinary, inclusive, participatory, cooperative, solidarity-oriented). Hence, trust and acceptance of the AI generated, even of contentious “surveillance” technologies, is enhanced since the digital innovation can be perceived as truly citizens-/humans-centred and society-oriented.