This study explores how corporate culture influences the relationship between ESG performance and default risk, using data from 4,524 firms across 2002–2023. Findings reveal a positive and significant association between ESG performance—especially the environmental (E) and social (S) dimensions—and reduced default risk, measured through Merton’s distance-to-default. Companies with strong corporate cultures show a stronger connection between ESG performance and lower default risk. The effect is more prominent in mature firms. Two additional moderating factors—pollution intensity and regulatory enforcement—are also examined. In heavily polluting industries, firms with robust cultures exhibit an even stronger ESG-default risk relationship. Moreover, in countries with weaker enforcement, corporate culture plays a key role in mitigating risk both directly and by enhancing ESG’s effectiveness. Robustness checks support all results, emphasizing the importance of integrating ESG strategies with corporate culture and external context to better manage financial risk.