This study analyzes the potential of group-based negotiation processes based on changes in reasoning and argument weighting for a socioscientific issue (SSI) in biology classes. In the corresponding pre- and post-study, students were encouraged to reason and weight arguments about the conservation of local biodiversity before and after a group-based negotiation. For this purpose, the students employed a target-mat structuring tool for compensatory reasoning and weighting in both the individual pre- and post-phases and the group phase. To identify changes in reasoning after group-based negotiation, the use of argumentative resources, i.e., fact-based and normative resources, was assessed. When the students added confirming reasons for arguments, they were more likely to use fact-based resources. When refuting the initial reasoning, the students tended to add normative resources. Furthermore, individual changes in weightings and their relationship to the group weighting were calculated. This analysis revealed that the students changed their weightings toward the group weighting. The results are discussed in terms of the potential of negotiations to cause students to revise and rethink their reasoning and weighting in addressing SSIs and the particular potential of the target-mat instructional tool for structured decision-making.
There is a need for support in addressing complex socio-scientific issues (SSIs) in science lessons. Therefore, this study analyzes the quality of students’ group discussions against the background of functionally varying degrees of instruction to enhance both complexity management and broad participation. The instructional approach comprises a process-structuring tool, target-mat, as the core of the teaching strategy. The corresponding intervention was conducted in 29 group discussions regarding a local biodiversity conflict among 8th-grade students. On the basis of qualitative content analysis and subsequent code quantification, the results indicate that directly instructed discussion activities, such as compliance with discussion phases, were successfully realized. In addition, discussion activities that were not explicitly instructed, such as active participation and referring to peers’ statements in terms of transactivity, were, nevertheless, frequently observed. Furthermore, the frequency of these noninstructed activities correlates significantly with the controversial character of the discussion topic. These results are attributed to the balanced combination of guided and student-directed activities and are interpreted as core features of discussion quality. The implications for teaching and educational research are discussed.
Group discussions enable argumentative development and are considered as a core strategy for addressing socioscientific issues (SSIs). Yet, in SSIs, students often struggle to navigate the decision-making process. This has increased interest in scaffolds that make both the process and the factual and normative complexity manageable. Although effects on the discussion process have been researched, little is known about whether structured discussion influences dispositions for future engagement, including discussion-related attitudes, communicative self-efficacy, and environmental attitudes. Therefore, this study investigated group discussions on three SSIs with 56 secondary students from four 7th- and 8th-grade classes at two German schools. In the experimental condition, discussions were supported by a scaffold called Target-Mat, which visually structured the discussion steps; the control condition used a familiar pro–con table. Pre–post questionnaires measured communicative self-efficacy, discussion-related attitudes, and environmental attitudes; group × time interactions were analyzed using a mixed ANOVA. Results showed significant group × time interactions for communicative self-efficacy (partial η2 = 0.09), discussion-related attitudes (partial η2 = 0.09), and environmental opinion (partial η2 = 0.08), but not environmental emotion. These findings indicate that structured discussions can positively influence relevant dispositions for future participation. The implications for teaching and educational research are discussed.