This study evaluates the hydraulic and water-quality performance of two full-scale Sustainable Urban Drainage Systems (SUDS), a permeable pavement (PP) and a filter drain (FD), treating urban runoff in Valencia (Spain) under a Mediterranean rainfall pattern. Rainfall, flow, and event-based water quality were monitored over one year at a conventional gully (CG, road runoff) and at both SUDS outflows. Analysed parameters included conventional pollutants (TSS, COD, BOD, TN, TP), hydrocarbons (C06-C10, C10–C28, C29–C40, PAHs), and 12 trace metals/metalloids. Both systems exhibited high hydraulic resilience, with volumetric efficiencies consistently exceeding 66% and total retention during events under 20 mm; notably, the FD achieved 100% retention up to 30 mm. Peak flows were significantly delayed and attenuated. Concentration-based metrics (Event Mean Concentration, EMC) yielded moderate, event-dependent reductions and occasional negative efficiencies for specific metals. Conversely, pollutographs revealed substantial peak concentration attenuation (often >50%), while mass-based indicators (area-normalized Pollutant Mass Loading, PML) confirmed consistently high load reductions (generally >70%). These results persist even when outflow EMCs exceeded inflow values, primarily due to runoff volume reduction. These findings underscore the necessity of integrating concentration and load-based metrics to prevent underestimating SUDS mitigation performance under high-intensity, variable rainfall regimes.