Emergency vehicles (EVs) are at high risk of accidents during emergency driving. To make use of countermeasures to mitigate these risks, it is important to understand under what circumstances EV-related accidents occur. The common risk factors for EV-related accidents were examined through a systematic literature review. A total of 22 articles were examined for risk factors associated with EV-related accidents. The most reported risk factors were, in order of frequency, intersections, daytime, dry roads, clear weather, urban roads, traffic signals, and angular collisions. The articles were also reviewed for suggested countermeasures to mitigate the risk factors. The most commonly suggested countermeasures were driver training for EV operators, educating the public, exercising caution at intersections, wearing a seatbelt, and intelligent vehicle technologies. Cooperative intelligent transport systems (C-ITSs) have the potential to mitigate the risks of EV-related accidents. Therefore, three C-ITS services were investigated: EV approaching, EV preemption, and geofencing. They could all be used to inform, warn, or control aspects of driving. Each suggested service has the potential to decrease risk factors for EV-related accidents. The current literature review provides guidance on under what circumstance and in what form C-ITSs could be beneficial to prevent EV-related accidents. Further research is needed to examine behavior when drivers are introduced to C-ITSs.
29 November 2023 in Human Factors: The Journal of the Human Factors and Ergonomics Society
Objective: This study investigated drivers’ move-over behavior when receiving an Emergency Vehicle Approaching (EVA) warning. Furthermore, the possible effects of false alarms, driver experience, and modality on move-over behavior were explored. Background: EVA warnings are one solution to encourage drivers to move over for emergency vehicles in a safe and timely manner. EVA warnings are distributed based on the predicted path of the emergency vehicle causing a risk of false alarms. Previous EVA studies have suggested a difference between inexperienced and experienced drivers’ move-over behavior. Method: A driving simulator study was conducted with 110 participants, whereof 54 inexperienced and 56 experienced drivers. They were approached by an emergency vehicle three times. A control group received no EVA warnings, whereas the experimental groups received either true or false warnings, auditory or visual, 15 seconds before the emergency vehicle overtook them. Results: Drivers who received EVA warnings moved over more quickly for the emergency vehicle compared to the control group. Drivers moved over more quickly for each emergency vehicle interaction. False alarms impaired move-over behavior. No difference in driver behavior based on driver experience or modality was observed. Conclusion: EVA warnings positively affect drivers’ move-over behavior. However, false alarms can decrease drivers’ future willingness to comply with the warning. Application: The findings regarding measurements of delay can be used to optimize the design of future EVA systems. Moreover, this research should be used to further understand the effect of false alarms in in-car warnings.
10 December 2024 in Transportation Research Interdisciplinary Perspectives
Emergency vehicle lightings (EVL) mitigate the risk of collision and make drivers move over. The present paper explored how new alternative EVL designs can improve driver behavior in different emergency vehicle interaction scenarios. From workshops with 14 emergency responders, three scenarios (Emergency driving, Police pull-over, Emergency vehicle alongside the road) and 19 EVL blink patterns were chosen. These alternative EVLs were presented in an online survey with 2627 Swedish respondents. Alternative EVL affected reported driving behavior. Drivers reported being most certain of what is expected from them in the emergency-driving scenario. It is important to ensure that the EVL is easy to interpret in more unfamiliar emergency-vehicle interactions such as police pull-over. Only a third of drivers had seen the pull-over EVL currently used in Sweden. The current pull-over EVL in combination with a stop sign increased the chance of drivers reporting that they would pull over.
17 December 2024 in Acta Polytechnica CTU Proceedings
Emergency driving is a demanding task. The ITS service Emergency Vehicle Approaching provides drivers with an in-car warning that an emergency vehicle is approaching. To ensure that the warning is efficient and reliable it must have a suitable timing. The EVA warning must be presented early enough to allow the driver to make a safe move-over maneuver. However, the distribution of EVA warnings is based on the most probable path of the emergency vehicle. If an EVA warning is distributed too early, it increases the risk of false alarms. In addition, if a warning is given too early the driver might deem it as irrelevant.Previous studies have distributed EVA warnings based on the distance between the emergency vehicle and surrounding cars. However, if the speed of the vehicle is not accounted for there is a risk of insufficient time for the driver to prepare for the emergency vehicle interaction. To explore suitable EVA timing, post-survey data from five driving simulator studies where drivers were exposed to EVA warnings were analyzed. The results suggest that 15–20 seconds could be an appropriate EVA timing. However, the required time for a move-over maneuver depends on the complexity of the current traffic situation.