Purpose Little is known about phenotypes, diagnoses and sex of rearing (SR) of infants with atypical genital development in the United States. As part of a multi-center study of these infants, we provide a baseline report from US difference/disorder of sex development (DSD) clinics describing diagnoses, anatomic features and SR. We also aim to determine whether Consensus guidelines are followed for sex designation in the US. Methods Eligible participants had moderate-to-severe genital atypia, age <3 years and no prior genitoplasty. Karyotype, genetic diagnosis, DSD etiology, family history and SR were collected. Standardized exam was performed. Results Of 92 subjects, karyotypes were: 57% 46,XX, 34% 46,XY, and 9% sex chromosome abnormality. Median age at baseline evaluation was 8.8 months. Most 46,XX subjects had congenital adrenal hyperplasia (CAH) (91%) and most 46,XY subjects (65%) did not have a known diagnosis. Two individuals with CAH underwent a change in SR from male to female within 2 weeks of birth. Presence of a uterus and shorter phallic length were associated with female SR. The most common karyotype and diagnosis was 46,XX with CAH followed by 46,XY with unknown diagnosis. Phenotypically, atypical genitalia are most commonly characterized by abnormal labioscrotal tissue, phallic length and urethral meatus location. Conclusions Increased phallic length was positively associated with rearing male. Among US centers studied, sex designation followed Consensus Statement recommendations. Further study is needed to determine if this results in patient satisfaction.