Lowships" and "alienations" that many pacifists facedwhen theyinsistedon putting theirvalues into action (p. 8). Alienation is theoverriding focus of two of the ten chapters, "TheMob Scene atMcNeil" ? "it takes an intricate succession of misfor tunes and blunders to getmobbed by your own countrymen," writes Stafford ? and "The End of the War" (p. 15).Butmuch of thebook presents the camps as places where men cre ated communities inopposition to theviolence unfolding in theworld. One chapter describes "ACO Wedding" while another depicts family lifeat the camps and a third addresses mysti cism and spiritual growth. One of themost moving chapters, "The Battle of Anapamu Creek," follows several COs as they confront a disapproving Forest Service supervisor and convince him to change his behavior through a constructive and humanistic process. Threads of division and personal struggleare never far in thebackground, however, as theyoungmen of CPS search for themeans to "make [their] protest clean" (p. 90). It isnot clear by the end of the book how George will emerge from World War II and his stint inprison. Not a fullyfleshed-out charac ter, George isa device toguide readers through theharshness and ambiguity ofCPS. Stafford, on theotherhand, comes out ofhis experiences at CPS anything but disillusioned. His work as a poet, teacher, and Oregon's poet laureate was infusedwith his early belief in pacifism and the lessons he learned at the camps. In his powerful introduction to theOregon State University Press reprintedition, Stafford'sson Kim Stafford writes, "I thinkfor the restof his lifehemissed that intensityof purpose he had felt in camp" (p.xiii). Kim Stafford's introduction, written de cades after the original text,provides some of thehistorical context not addressed in the memoir and ties his father's observations to contemporary conflicts. He advises readers that the text provides a means to "learn peace ? not as an abstraction, but as a skill" (p. vii). Together the twopoets provide uswith a com pelling historyand first-personnarrative of the pacifist legacy ofWorld War II, a legacy that is often overshadowed by the fighting of the war. This book isameaningful and important contribution to thehistory ofOregon (home to several CPS camps) and one of itsfinest residents, aswell as to itsartisticheritage. Katrine Barber Portland State University PUBLICPOWER,PRIVATE DAMS: THEHELL'SCANYONHIGHDAM CONTROVERSY byKarl BoydBrooks University of Washington Press, Seattle, 2006. Photographs, maps, notes, index. 319 pages. $35.00 cloth. This splendid book isa convincing account of the post-WorldWar II, decade-long legal and political struggles todefine a hydroelectric fu tureforthePacificNorthwest. The conflict was framed as a great referendum on thequestion of public or private power, and it was debated in the highest strata of presidential politics while itproceeded through the legal channels (notably the Federal Power Commission) to which it was assigned. In theend,private power (represented by the Idaho Power Company) won permission tobuild itsthree"small" dams inHell's Canyon on the Snake River between Idaho and Oregon (Brownlee, Oxbow, and Hell's Canyon Dam) while the federal govern ment abandoned itsplans to build theHell's Canyon High Dam ? theworld's highestwith a ninety-three-mile reservoir behind it.And in the end of the end, the Snake River salmon would be all but gone and the age of environ mentalism would be upon us. Karl Boyd Brooks brings great strengths to the project. He is an attorneywith litigation experience on these very topics and a knack for expressing the anxieties and perturba tions of the "big case." He is an experienced former Idaho state senator who thoroughly 134 OHQ vol. 108, no. 1 understands the faults, folds, and fractures of law disguised as public policy. Brooks loves his home and geographical region, and he deftly enters the hearts and minds of the people who played out thisdrama. And he is an indefatigable and honest researcherwith a keen sense of the documents (not a few of them commonly overlooked) thatwill best point the way. The book isalso beautifully and carefully written. Itwill be in all of thePacific Northwest environmental collections for the foreseeable future. The author needs all his talents to sustain the tale.The environmental hero of the story, Idaho Power, is an unsympathetic David to theGoliath of thefederal government. Brooks trieshard: "More modest dams...