Purpose: Previous work has shown that judgments of emotion differ between clear and conversational speech, particularly for perceived anger. The current study examines talker differences in perceived emotion for a database of talkers producing clear and conversational speech. Method: A database of 41 talkers was used to assess talker differences in six emotion categories (“Anger,” “Fear,” “Disgust,” “Happiness,” “Sadness,” and “Neutral”). Twenty-six healthy young adult listeners rated perceived emotion in 14 emotionally neutral sentences produced in clear and conversational styles by all talkers in the database. Generalized linear mixed-effects modeling was utilized to examine talker differences in all six emotion categories. Results: There was a significant effect of speaking style for all emotion categories, and substantial talker differences existed after controlling for speaking style in all categories. Additionally, many emotion categories, including anger, had significant Talker × Style interactions. Perceived anger was significantly higher in clear speech compared to conversational speech for 85% of the talkers. Conclusions: While there is a large speaking style effect for perceived anger, the magnitude of the effect varies between talkers. The perception of negatively valenced emotions in clear speech, including anger, may result in unintended interpersonal consequences for those utilizing clear speech as a communication facilitator. Further research is needed to examine potential acoustic sources of perceived anger in clear speech. Supplemental Material: https://doi.org/10.23641/asha.28304384
Purpose: Voice-specialized speech-language pathologists have been performing stimulability testing since at least the 1970s. However, definitions of stimulability testing vary widely within the current literature, leading to wide variability in stimulability testing practices. To determine the degree of consensus regarding stimulability testing, the current scoping review collected and analyzed the definitions of stimulability testing and stimulability testing outcomes amongst current peer-reviewed literature regarding voice disorders. Methods: A literature search was conducted in PubMed, EBSCOhost, and Google Scholar for peer-reviewed articles containing the terms “stimulability” or “stimulable”. Articles including information regarding the behavioral assessment of patients with voice disorders were included. Results: 88 articles were included in the review. Only 20% of articles provided a definition of stimulability testing or stimulability testing outcomes; over half (52%) mentioned search terminology in passing without any further definition or description, and the remaining quarter (27%) described stimulability testing or stimulability testing outcomes rather than providing a definition. Thematic analysis of stimulability testing suggested that most authors describe the practice as involving modifying patient behaviors, assessing patient responses, and using facilitators. While definitions of stimulability testing outcomes shared thematic similarities, details within the definitions varied substantially. Conclusion: Stimulability testing and stimulability testing outcomes are infrequently defined within the current literature. Results of the thematic analysis suggest consensus on the common elements of stimulability testing, but not stimulability testing outcomes. Given the clinical importance of stimulability testing, increased care is needed in future work to provide full and adequate definitions of both stimulability testing and stimulability testing outcomes in future work.
In the study of auditory emotion perception, it is important to calibrate test sounds so their presentation level during testing is known. It is also often desirable to standardize the amplitude of the sounds so that each sound used in testing is approximately the same level. However, existing literature in the study of auditory emotion perception includes a mixture of techniques for standardizing amplitude across sounds. The purpose of this study was to compare the effects of two amplitude-scaling approaches on emotional responses to non-speech sounds, specifically standardization based on peak level or root-mean-square (rms) level. Nineteen young adults provided ratings of valence and arousal via an online testing program. Stimuli were non-speech sounds scaled in two ways, based on the stimulus’ peak level or rms level. Ratings were analyzed using linear-mixed effects modeling to compare scaling methods; correlations between ratings and level within each scaling method were explored. Analysis revealed that the ratings of peak-scaled sounds were less pleasant and more exciting than were the ratings of rms-scaled sounds, although the effects were small in magnitude (~0.2 points on a 1–9 scale). Within rms-scaled sounds, peak level was not related to ratings of valence or arousal. However, within peak-scaled sounds, rms level was related to ratings of valence and arousal. Combined, these data suggest that amplitude standardization has a small effect on ratings overall, but investigators might be motivated to choose one approach over the other, depending on the research question. Rms-scaling reduces overall level as a cue for emotional responses, while peak-scaling maintains some natural variability in responses related to level. Finally, results are specific to this stimulus set. The effects of amplitude-scaling would be expected to be negligible for a stimulus set where the sounds have homogenous temporal dynamics.
13 October 2023 in International Journal of Speech-Language Pathology
Purpose: Non-invasive ventilation (NIV) provides respiratory support without invasive endotracheal intubation but can hinder patients' ability to communicate effectively. The current study presents preliminary results using a novel in-mask ventilator microphone to enhance talker intelligibility while receiving NIV.Method: A proof-of-concept study assessed sentence intelligibility of five healthy adult talkers using a prototype model of the microphone under continuous positive airway pressure (CPAP; 5/5 cm H2O) and bilevel positive airway pressure (BiPAP; 8/4 cm H2O) ventilator conditions. A pilot study then assessed intelligibility, subjective comprehensibility and naturalness, and patient- and conversation partner-reported communication outcomes for eight patients undergoing therapeutic NIV while being treated in an intensive care unit (ICU).Result: Intelligibility increased significantly with the microphone on in the BiPAP condition for healthy volunteers. For patients undergoing NIV in an ICU, intelligibility, comprehensibility, and patient and conversation partner ratings of conversation satisfaction significantly improved with the microphone on. Patients with lower baselines without the microphone in certain measures (intelligibility, comprehensibility) generally showed a greater microphone benefit than patients with higher baselines.Conclusion: Use of a novel microphone integrated into NIV improved intelligibility during ventilation for both healthy volunteers and patients undergoing therapeutic NIV. Additional clinical studies will define precise benefits and implications of such improved intelligibility.