The article analyses the trust relationship between principals and teachers in primary schools in the specific Chilean educational context. The analysis is based on the concept of school trust, emphasizing Bryk and Tschannen-Moran’s classic works. A mixed sequential quantitative–qualitative research methodology is used, including both a survey and a qualitative case study carried out in nine schools. The main results, include: principals and teachers take a different approach when forging trust they have in one another. While principals confer this trust, teachers earn it. Likewise, principals mainly set the tone, intensity and scope of the trust relationship; principals are more critical of teachers, mainly questioning certain aspects of their professional skills. Conversely, teachers normally base trust on more personal matters; individual traits of both principals and teachers have little impact on their relational trust, the exception being the number of years teachers have been on the job. While for teachers there are hardly any differences (and this changes only when it comes to the prevailing principal’s leadership), among principals, differences emerge from schools’ size, socio-economic level and public or private status; and a final discussion propounds the importance of the educational context when analysing trust relationships and positional power in schools.
<!--GALEY ICONS--> <!-- END ICONS--> PDF <!--end #articleFullText--> En la última década, en Chile se ha puesto en marcha una serie de políticas destinadas a fomentar el liderazgo educativo. Sin embargo, poco se sabe acerca de las características de la investigación que se ha realizado en esta temática. Esta revisión topográfica analiza de manera sistemática los artículos en torno al liderazgo educativo en Chile, que cuentan con una base de investigación empírica y que fueron publicados en revistas indexadas en el período comprendido entre 2008 y 2019. Los resultados muestran que se han publicado 47 artículos, con un aumento sustantivo desde el año 2016 en adelante. Dichos artículos han sido publicados por un grupo de 85 autores, no obstante, la mayoría de ellos solo ha publicado un artículo. Las investigaciones se caracterizan por ser mayoritariamente descriptivas y cualitativas, siendo escasas las que han realizado muestreo de tipo aleatorio o que han explotado los datos secundarios existentes. Un 40% de los artículos declara no haber contado con recursos para desarrollar su investigación. Los focos de investigación más estudiados han sido los directores, así como las escuelas municipales. Las publicaciones se han concentrado en revistas latinoamericanas e indexadas en Scopus. La caracterización realizada permite considerar al campo de estudio como emergente, sugiriéndose un conjunto de medidas que permitirían su consolidación.
27 May 2021 in Educational Management Administration & Leadership
What differences are there, according to teachers’ opinions, in school leadership practices between male principals (MPs) and female principals (FPs) in urban primary schools in Chile? A national survey has been done to address this topic, which was answered by the principal and five teachers in 381 urban primary schools. Following Leithwood’s school leadership four-category model, 14 practices were considered and measured. Data were analysed by statistical procedures, including the decision tree technique, chi-squared automatic interaction detection (CHAID). Findings showed that in 9 out of 14 practices, FPs have a significantly more favourable evaluation from teachers. Data confirmed that, when compared to other personal traits of principals or school features, gender is the strongest independent variable related with leadership practices. Nonetheless, this advantage occurs in an overall scenario in which both FPs and MPs engage unevenly with the leadership practices across the dimensions of the model. This study does not aim to explain the female advantage, but to show the shape of leadership differences by gender regarding theoretically relevant practices. Nevertheless, its data allow ruling out some possible hypotheses for interpreting those differences. The article suggests that further research is needed to theoretically explain the reasons behind differences in leadership practice by FPs and MPs.
18 September 2017 in Educational Management Administration & Leadership
Latin American educational policy has relied on the assumption that better preparation can help school leaders improve their professional performance, thus improving quality of schools. Training programs for present or future school leaders have proliferated in the region, often publicly financed, but without enough evidence of their impact. Using data for seven Latin American countries from the Third Regional Comparative and Explanatory Study (TERCE), we seek to determine the association between school leaders’ formal education and training received, with well recognized dimensions of school leadership practices reported by their teachers. We estimated linear regression models for each country in Latin America to determine the relationship between principals’ preparation with indicators of educational leadership practices. Our results show that in most observed indicators of leadership practices the effect of education or training is marginal. We provide possible explanations for this finding, emphasizing the weaknesses in principals’ initial selection processes and their deficiencies. We also consider schools’ precarious conditions to support principals in order to put the knowledge they learned in training activities into practice. We point out the need to continue conducting specific studies on the effects of training on educational leadership among school leaders in the region, overcoming TERCE information restrictions.
The article analyzes the recent evolution of school leadership in Chile between 2009 and 2019, a decade of significant intensification in the country’s school leadership policies, comparing principals’ characteristics, working conditions and leadership practices, as reported by school principals and teachers. Data comes from a survey applied in both years to principals and teachers in nationally representative samples of urban primary schools. While reports of some characteristics and working conditions of principals have changed, no significant variation occurred in teachers’ perceptions of principals’ leadership practices. The article discusses policy´s capacity to motivate principals’ practice change at the local level.