Aigul Myltykbayeva

Dr. Aigul Myltykbayeva


Research Focus & Metrics

Representative Publications

View All Publications
5 November 2026 in Economies
Verified
Journal Article
Open access
PDF file
BABaurzhan Antonov
Baurzhan Antonov
Aisulu MoldabekovaAisulu Moldabekova
Aisulu Moldabekova
AMAigul Myltykbayeva
Aigul Myltykbayeva
Rural development policy increasingly relies on indicators, yet whether composite measures of rural well-being are coherent or whether regional growth reaches rural residents are rarely tested. Using official statistics for 14 oblasts of Kazakhstan over 2018–2024, we build a Rural Social Well-Being Index from five rural-specific indicators: poverty, infant mortality, housing, employment and preschool enrolment. The dimensions are weakly related, so a dashboard of separate indicators is more informative than is a single score. We distinguish within-oblast associations, which describe change over time inside an oblast, from between-oblast differences, which compare richer and poorer oblasts. Within oblasts, two-way fixed-effects models with wild cluster bootstrap inference suggest that a 10% higher real gross regional product is associated with about 1.1 percentage points lower rural poverty, but this association does not survive multiple-testing correction, and we find no evidence of links with other rural outcomes or local public spending. Between oblasts, richer oblasts are not found to have lower rural poverty. A Rural Conversion Gap, defined as the deviation of rural poverty from the level predicted by economic capacity, consistently ranks oblasts, although no oblast is a statistical outlier. The estimates are associations, not causal effects.

17 November 2026 in Preprints.org
Verified
Preprint
Open access
PDF file
BABaurzhan Antonov
Baurzhan Antonov
Aisulu MoldabekovaAisulu Moldabekova
Aisulu Moldabekova
AMAigul Myltykbayeva
Aigul Myltykbayeva
Evidence on place-based rural investment from resource-dependent, post-socialist and fiscally centralised economies is scarce. We assess Kazakhstan's Auyl–El Besigi programme, which financed infrastructure in selected villages in 2019–2025. Programme exposure was reconstructed from 1106 final amended budget decisions for the main sample of 135 rural districts, drawn from a broader collection of 1298 distinct decisions for 2019–2026, and linked to official statistics and Visible Infrared Imaging Radiometer Suite (VIIRS) night-time lights. Callaway–Sant'Anna difference-in-differences estimates against not-yet-funded districts cover a window ending in 2021 (2022 as a robustness check); later years are analysed descriptively. Early-funded districts had about twice the rural population of later entrants. After covariate adjustment, short-run estimates are small and imprecise: 0.021 log points for night-time light (95% confidence interval −0.035 to 0.076) and 0.008 for average wages (−0.006 to 0.022). No robust short-run district-level effect was detectable using the available administrative and satellite indicators. Trends to 2024–2025 are similar across entry groups, and larger recorded allocations coincide descriptively with faster wage growth. The findings highlight a broader evaluation problem for centrally financed place-based programmes in data-constrained institutional settings: without settlement-level project, expenditure and service-quality records, economically meaningful local effects may remain undetectable in aggregate administrative data.