This study presents a social life cycle assessment (S-LCA) of the F-CUBED Production System (FPS), an innovative process that converts wet biogenic residues—specifically paper biosludge, virgin olive pomace, and fruit and vegetable residues—into intermediate bioenergy carriers via hydrothermal treatment (TORWASH®), pelletization, and anaerobic digestion. The hydrothermal carbonization of these low-grade, moisture-rich biogenic residues enhances the flexibility and reliability of renewable energy systems while also offering the potential to reduce environmental burdens compared to conventional disposal methods. Through this S-LCA, the study aims to evaluate the cradle-to-gate socioeconomic impacts of the FPS in three European contexts—Sweden, Italy, and Spain—using the 2020 UNEP Guidelines and the Social Hotspots Database (SHDB) and applying quantitative modeling via SimaPro. The functional unit is defined as 1 kWh of electricity produced. The assessment combines SHDB-based modeling with primary data from stakeholder surveys conducted in the three countries. Impact categories are harmonized between SHDB and UNEP typologies, and the results are reported in medium-risk-hour equivalents (mrheq). The results show a heterogeneous social impact profile across case studies. In Sweden, the treatment of paper biosludge delivers substantial benefits with minimal risk. In Spain (orange peel), the introduction of the FPS demonstrated a strong social benefit, particularly in health and safety and labor rights, indicating high institutional performance and good integration with local industry. Conversely, in Italy (olive pomace), the FPS revealed significant social risks, especially in the biopellet production and electricity generation sectors, reflecting regional vulnerabilities in labor conditions and governance. This suggests that targeted mitigation strategies are recommended in contexts like Southern Italy. These findings highlight that the social sustainability of emerging bioenergy technologies is context-dependent and sensitive to sectoral and regional socioeconomic conditions. This S-LCA complements prior environmental assessments and emphasizes the importance of integrating social performance considerations in the deployment and scaling of innovative bioenergy systems.
This study presents a Social Life Cycle Assessment (S-LCA) of the F-CUBED Production System, an innovative process that converts wet biogenic residues - specifically paper bio-sludge, olive pomace, and orange peel - into intermediate bioenergy carriers via hydrothermal treatment (TORWASH®), palletisation, and anaerobic digestion. Hydrothermal carbonization of low quality, wet biogenic residues into intermediate bioenergy carriers potentially contribute to a more flexible and stable renewable energy system and reduce environmental impacts compared to current residue disposal practices. Through the S-LCA, this study intends to evaluate both potential risks and benefits of this novel technology for key stakeholder categories (e.g., workers, local communities, value chain actors) in three EU contexts: Sweden, Italy, and Spain. The assessment applies the 2020 UNEP S-LCA Guidelines and leverages the Social Hotspots Database (SHDB) to evaluate the cradle-to-gate social and socio-economic impacts of the system. The study integrates quantitative modeling in SimaPro and data from stakeholder surveys. By integrating experimental data and process modeling, the study emphasizes the necessity of considering social dimensions alongside environmental impacts to ensure societal acceptance and policy relevance. Results reveal that, while the technology offers social benefits such as employment and economic development, particularly in Sweden and Spain, moderate social risks persist, especially in the Italian case (olive pomace), related to sectors like Electricity generation and Biopellets production. The findings underscore the importance of holistic sustainability assessments for emerging bioenergy technologies and provide actionable insights for stakeholders and policymakers aiming to advance sustainable and socially responsible bioenergy systems.