The increasing use of Generative AI raises many ethical, philosophical, and legal issues. A key issue here is uncertainties about how different degrees of Generative AI assistance in the production of text impacts assessments of the human authorship of that text. To explore this issue, we developed an experimental mixed methods survey study (N = 602) asking participants to reflect on a scenario of a human author receiving assistance to write a short novel as part of a 3 (high, medium, or low degrees of assistance) X 2 (human or AI assistant) factorial design. We found that, for a human author, the degree of assistance they receive matters for our assessments of their level of authorship, creatorship, and responsibility, but not what or who rendered that assistance, although it was more important to disclose human rather than AI assistance. However, in our assessments of the assisting agent, human assistants were viewed as warranting higher rates of authorship, creatorship, and responsibility, compared to AI assistants rendering the same level of support. These results help us to better understand emerging norms around collaborative human-AI generated text, with implications for other types of collaborative content creation.
14 May 2020 in Journal of Intellectual Property Law and Practice
As artificial intelligence (AI) technologies are increasingly involved in the creation of music, works of arts, poems and even film scripts, a critical legal issue is the nature and ambit of copyright protection that should be afforded to AI-generated works. As Andres Guadamuz compellingly notes, ‘[t]he rise of the machines is here, but they do not come as conquerors, they come as creators’. 1 While there are many and varying definitions of AI, for the present purpose, the concept is best understood as referring to the simulation, by a machine entity, of the cognitive aspects of human thinking. 2 Such simulation of human intelligence processes by computer systems encompass both automated learning and automated reasoning. Automated learning refers to the process by which AI systems acquire information and apply predetermined rules for using that information; automated reasoning refers to the process by which such systems use these rules to reach approximate or definite conclusions. Important features of AI reasoning involves learning from past experiences and self-correction. 3 At present, the nature and ambit of copyright protection extended to works generated using AI differs across jurisdictions, with significant divergences in the both the principles governing copyright authorship and ownership and those governing infringement. In such a context, the objective of the present article is to consider the appropriate ambit of copyright protection that should be extended to AI-generated works. The article will begin by providing a brief international overview of present copyright laws in this area, proceed to considering the evolving law reform discourse, most notably the ongoing World Intellectual Property Organization (WIPO) inquiry, 4 and culminate by considering options to refine and clarify copyright law in this critical area.
1 June 2022 in International Journal of Law and Information Technology
Despite its exponential growth, artificial intelligence (AI) in healthcare faces various challenges. One of them is a lack of explainability of AI medical devices, which arguably leads to insufficient trust in AI technologies, quality, and accountability and liability issues. The aim of this paper is to examine whether, why and to what extent AI explainability should be demanded with relation to AI-enabled medical devices and their outputs. Relying on a critical analysis of interdisciplinary literature on this topic and an empirical study, we conclude that the role of AI explainability in the medical AI context is a limited one. If narrowly defined, AI explainability principle is capable of addressing only a limited range of challenges associated with AI and is likely to reach fewer goals than sometimes expected. The study shows that, instead of technical explainability of medical AI devices, most stakeholders need more transparency around its development and quality assurance process.
14 February 2022 in SCRIPTed: A Journal of Law, Technology & Society
By Rita Matulionyte and Jyh-An Lee. In Thaler v The Comptroller-General of Patents, Designs and Trade Marks (DABUS), Smith J. held that an AI owner can possibly claim patent ownership over an AI-generated invention based on their ownership and control of the AI system. This AI-owner approach reveals a new option to allocate property rights over AI-generated output. While this judgment was primarily about inventorship and ownership of AI-generated invention in patent law, it has important implications for copyright law. After analysing the weaknesses of applying existing judicial approaches to copyright ownership of AI-generated works, this paper examines whether the AI-owner approach is a better option for determining copyright ownership of AI-generated works. The paper argues that while contracts can be used to work around the AI-owner approach in scenarios where users want to commercially exploit the outputs, this approach still provides more certainty and less transaction costs for relevant parties than other approaches proposed so far.
This article explores publishing as a creative system and examines the changes brought by the emergence of digital technologies on this sector of the creative industries, specifically the proliferation of self-publishing. The paper examines the deep background of changes in thinking on creativity as well as the evolution of self-publishing, before focusing in on the specific legal challenges that self-publishing authors face. These challenges include questions surrounding collaboration and community-sourced services and the identification of co-authors who would also have legal rights invested in the final product as well as issues surrounding fan-fiction, which is especially popular among self-publishing authors. Linked to these are the challenges surrounding the protection of works published online, which is especially difficult for self-published authors who often work without the legal knowledge, experience and resources that traditional publishers have previously provided to enforce copyright. These and other issues raise the question as to the extent the current legal structure of copyright corresponds to the new realities facing the publishing sector and whether this underpinning legal framework satisfactorily serves this creative system in action.
1 November 2008 in The Journal of World Intellectual Property