Industrialization, which has changed with the development of innovation and technology, has accelerated the consumption of energy and natural resources while satisfying customer expectations. Sustainable industrialization is an essential concept to meet the needs of present and future generations. There is a critical need to reveal the sustainable industrialization levels of the countries. Countries that can determine their current situation within the scope of sustainable industrialization can also identify open to improvement areas more quickly. In this study, a novel approach is proposed to evaluate the sustainable industrialization performance of European Union (EU) member countries. In the proposed approach, the evaluation criteria consist of 3 main criteria: environmental, economic, and social, with 16 sub-criteria. The importance weights of criteria are determined by the Spherical Fuzzy Analytic Hierarchy Process (SF-AHP) then countries are ranked according to sustainable industrialization performance with the Grey Relational Analysis (GRA) method considering the weights of the evaluation criteria. The proposed method is applied to EU member countries, taking into account the 2018 data. As a result of the application, according to the sustainable industrialization performance, the top five countries are determined as Sweden, Germany, Netherlands, Luxembourg, and Denmark. This study is among the first to evaluate sustainable industrialization performances of EU member countries. The study’s outcomes can help researchers and policymakers have an opinion about the sustainable industrialization levels of countries
1 December 2016 in Computers & Industrial Engineering
Circular economy (CE), which has emerged with the integration of environmental science and sustainable development, has a significant contribution to human development and is a constantly developing concept that can be measured at the country, region, city, or enterprise level. Evaluating the CE performances of the European Union (EU) member countries at specific periods is crucial for monitoring their development. This study bridges the gap in the literature in terms of the method, dataset, and comparative analysis used while measuring the CE performances, and this is one of the first studies to look at the importance weights of CE criteria. In this study, a novel approach is proposed to evaluate the CE performances of EU member countries. The evaluation criteria are based on the European Commission CE monitoring framework in the proposed approach. The importance weights of criteria are determined using the fuzzy Simple Multi-Attribute Rating Technique (SMART) approach. The EU member countries are ranked according to their CE performances with the Combinative Distance-Based Assessment (CODAS) method considering the weights of the evaluation criteria. The proposed evaluation approach is applied by taking 2014, 2016, and 2018 years data into account. As a result of the application, according to the CE efficiency, the top five countries are the Netherlands, Luxembourg, Belgium, France, and Germany. The study’s findings can assist researchers and policymakers in gaining a better understanding of countries’ CE performance levels.
The energy needs of the world are increasing from day to day. The largest sources of energy currently used are fossil fuels. Non-renewable energy sources threaten the world as a result of many problems such as air, water and environmental pollution. The selection of energy sources is crucial for improving of countries. Different criteria must be evaluated simultaneously to select between renewable energy sources. In this study, a hybrid approach involving Fuzzy AHP and Fuzzy TOPSIS is suggested to select renewable energy sources. Proposed approach is presented with a case study for empirical evidence. In the case study, alternative energy sources were evaluated under four main criteria: (1) Technical, (2) Economical, (3) Environmental, (4) Social and Political. As a result of the 2-stage evaluation method including multi-criteria decision making techniques, wind energy was determined as the most suitable alternative.