Academic publishing is undergoing a fundamental transition, yet many of its institutional structures, evaluation criteria, and funding mechanisms still reflect the subscription era. This essay argues that the transition to Gold Open Access is not simply a change in business model but also a change in the rules of the publishing market. Using the analogy of moving from poker to chess, it contrasts a system based partly on restricted access and limited price transparency with one in which research findings, editorial processes, and publishing costs can become more visible. This essay examines several consequences of this transition: publish-or-perish incentives, repeated rejection and peer-review cycles, differing editorial concepts, and the often poorly defined notion of journal ‘quality’. It argues that highly selective journals have a legitimate role, but that the much larger group of mainstream journals requires different measures of value, including accessibility, transparency, publication speed, indexing, and usefulness to researchers. Finally, the essay proposes treating Gold Open Access and subscription publishing as one competitive market. Libraries, funders, and research institutions should evaluate both models within the same publishing budgets and according to transparent criteria, including price, indexing, peer-review practices, copyright retention, reuse rights, and editorial services. Such a framework could increase competition, improve transparency, and ultimately reduce the total cost of scholarly communication.