Investors who are about to retire are first and foremost concerned with supporting their spending needs throughout retirement. But they also derive satisfaction from growing their wealth beyond what is needed to support consumption in order to leave a bequest to their heirs or chosen charities. The predominant metric for evaluating retirement investment strategies is the failure rate. However, it fails to distinguish between strategies that fail early in retirement from those that fail near the end of retirement, and it fails to account for potential bequests. To overcome these shortcomings the authors propose a new metric, the coverage ratio, which is more comprehensive and informative than the failure rate. In addition, they propose a utility function to evaluate the coverage ratio, which penalizes shortfalls more than it rewards surpluses. Finally, the authors use their proposed framework to determine the optimal allocation to stocks and bonds using historical and simulated returns. TOPICS:Retirement, quantitative methods, portfolio construction
25 March 2018 in The Journal of Portfolio Management
The traditional approach to asset allocation is to identify the optimal allocation to broad asset classes based on assumptions for expected returns and risk. Increasingly, though, investors are choosing to stratify their portfolios into factors rather than traditional asset classes. Many investors, especially those who have qualitative views about macroeconomic factors, do not typically optimize exposure to factors based on explicit assumptions for return and risk. Instead, they pre-determine the appropriate factor exposures based on fundamental views and then identify combinations of assets that they perceive to capture the targeted factor exposures most effectively. Both approaches have their benefits and limitations. The authors propose a framework that integrates traditional asset allocation with factor investing in a way that emphasizes the benefits of each approach while helping to overcome their respective limitations.
2 July 2021 in The Journal of Portfolio Management
That investors should diversify their portfolios is a core principle of modern finance. Yet there are some periods in which diversification is undesirable. When the portfolio’s main growth engine performs well, investors prefer the opposite of diversification. An ideal complement to the growth engine would provide diversification when it performs poorly and unification when it performs well. Numerous studies have presented evidence of asymmetric correlations between assets. Unfortunately, this asymmetry is often of the undesirable variety: It is characterized by downside unification and upside diversification. In other words, diversification often disappears when it is most needed. In this article, the authors highlight a fundamental flaw in the way some prior studies have measured correlation asymmetry. Because they estimate downside correlations from subsamples in which both assets perform poorly, they ignore instances of successful diversification (i.e., periods in which one asset’s gains offset the other’s losses). The authors propose instead that investors measure what matters: the degree to which a given asset diversifies the main growth engine when it underperforms. This approach yields starkly different conclusions, particularly for asset pairs with low full-sample correlation. In this article, the authors review correlation mathematics, highlight the flaw in prior studies, motivate the correct approach, and present an empirical analysis of correlation asymmetry across major asset classes. TOPICS:Portfolio theory, portfolio construction, quantitative methods, statistical methods, performance measurement Key Findings ▪ There is strong empirical evidence that asset class correlations are asymmetric, which poses complications in portfolio construction. ▪ Investors prefer diversification when a portfolio’s main growth engine performs poorly and unification when it performs well. ▪ To measure correlation asymmetry caused by nonnormality, investors must adjust for changes in correlation that arise mathematically when part of a sample is excluded. ▪ Unlike prior research, investors should condition correlations on the performance of a single asset, not two assets.
30 June 2019 in The Journal of Portfolio Management
Crowded trades are often associated with bubbles. If investors can locate a bubble sufficiently early, they can profit from the run-up in prices. But to profit from a bubble, investors must exit the bubble before the sell-off erodes all of the profits. The authors propose two measures for managing exposure to bubbles. One measure, called asset centrality, locates crowded trading, which they show is often associated with the formation of bubbles. The other is a measure of relative value, which helps to separate crowding that occurs during a bubble’s run-up from crowding that occurs during a bubble’s sell-off. Neither measure by itself is sufficient for identifying the full cycle of a bubble, but the authors show that together these measures have the potential to locate bubbles in sectors and in factors as they begin to emerge and to identify exit points before they fully deflate. TOPICS:Portfolio construction, factors, risk premia, risk management
14 December 2020 in The Journal of Portfolio Management
Investors rely on the stock-bond correlation for a variety of tasks, such as forming optimal portfolios, designing hedging strategies, and assessing risk. Most investors estimate the stock–bond correlation simply by extrapolating the historical correlation of monthly returns; they assume that this correlation best characterizes the correlation of future annual or multiyear returns, but this approach is decidedly unreliable. The authors introduce four innovations for generating a reliable prediction of the stock-bond correlation. First, they show how to represent the correlation of single-period cumulative stock and bond returns in a way that captures how the returns drift during the period. Second, they identify fundamental predictors of the stock-bond correlation. Third, they model the stock–bond correlation as a function of the path of some fundamental predictors rather than single observations. Finally, they censor their sample to include only relevant observations, in which relevance has a precise mathematical definition. TOPICS:Portfolio management/multi-asset allocation, risk management, statistical methods Key Findings ▪ The stock-bond correlation is a critical component of many investment activities, such as forming optimal portfolios, designing hedging strategies, and assessing risk. ▪ Most investors estimate the correlation of longer-interval returns by extrapolating the correlation of past shorter-interval returns, but this approach is decidedly unreliable. ▪ By applying recent advances in quantitative methods, it is possible to generate reliable predictions of the correlation of longer-horizon stock and bond returns.
6 July 2020 in The Journal of Portfolio Management
Financial analysts assume that the reliability of predictions derived from regression analysis improves with sample size. This is thought to be true because larger samples tend to produce less noisy results than smaller samples. But this is not always the case. Some observations are more relevant than others, and often one can obtain more reliable predictions by censoring observations that are not sufficiently relevant. The authors introduce a methodology for identifying relevant observations by recasting the prediction of a regression equation as a weighted average of the historical values of the dependent variable, in which the weights are the relevance of the independent variables. This equivalence allows them to use a subset of more relevant observations to forecast the dependent variable. The authors apply their methodology to forecast factor returns from economic variables. TOPICS: Portfolio management/multi-asset allocation, risk management, quantitative methods Key Findings • The prediction from a linear regression equation is mathematically equivalent to a weighted average of the past values of the dependent variable, in which the weights are the relevance of the independent observations. • Relevance within this context is defined as the sum of statistical similarity and informativeness, both of which are defined as Mahalanobis distances. • Together, these features allow researchers to censor less relevant observations and derive more reliable predictions of the dependent variable.