Persistent odours are a major obstacle to plastic recycling and the circular use of recycled polymers. This study systematically investigated garlic odour removal from polypropylene using dynamic olfactometry combined with qualitative sensory evaluation. Probiotic- and enzymatic-based formulations were assessed under different cleaning times and in the absence or presence of a non-ionic surfactant. Deodorisation efficiency increased with cleaning time and reached maximum performance under surfactant-assisted conditions. Protease-based formulations produced the lowest residual odour levels and the most consistent statistical results, whereas probiotic systems showed condition-dependent behaviour and occasionally increased odour intensity, likely due to secondary volatile metabolite formation. Sensory analysis demonstrated that odour pleasantness does not correlate linearly with intensity, highlighting the importance of combining quantitative olfactometric measurements with perceptual descriptors. Overall, bioactive cleaning strategies represent a scalable approach to improve the sensory quality and reuse potential of recycled polypropylene. This work provides the first systematic comparison between both strategies.