As a contribution to heritage and memory studies informed by architectural relics and their imageries, using standard surveying techniques and official documentary evidence (aerial photographic, mapping and archival information), this case study traces the history of the forgotten upper portion of Kowloon (Walled) City, called in this work Upper City, that went up to the summit of a small adjacent hill. It attempts to explain the disappearance of the Upper City and its walls from official and public memory. This disappearance is partly in terms of the loss of the stone walls during Japan’s wartime occupation of Hong Kong, and partly in terms of the presence of post-World War II official sanctions on memory. The findings, relevant to built heritage conservation, reinforce the point that physical walls are important place reminders.
This short paper on the planning and development of the City of Kowloon (City) at its formative (pre-British colonial) stage as a walled Ch’ing ( Qing ) Dynasty military base, attempts to provide a reasonable account of the apparent in-completion of this imperially planned town. The account is based on a comparison of the written specifications of this City’s design in written narratives in Chinese official documents, and its actual physical configuration after 1847 as it appears in photos, maps, and written sources. The authors postulate that the abandonment of the originally-proposed dimensions, a “ Chun Hoi Lau ” ( Zhenhai Tower ) which venerated the god Pak Tei ( Beitei ) with a strong fung shui ( feng shui ) function, and an uphill gun (cannon) position, was due to local objective topographical and geotechnical constraints that were insurmountable given China’s perceived urgent military needs at the time.
This interdisciplinary article follows up on a discussion of the lighthouse as a public good in terms of planning in this journal by elucidating the neo-institutional economic proposition that views of building facades along streets are common property and are public goods in the sense that their consumption is mutually non-exclusive. Hence, planning interventions are justified from an economic point of view to ensure the adequate supply of this good. This proposition is set within the context of the arguments for and against a lighthouse being a public good with reference to Coase’s 1974 paper and recent interpretations. Some planning implications are discussed. This article was published open access under a CC BY-NC-ND licence: https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc-nd/4.0/ .