Assimilation of weather radar measurements including radar reflectivity and radial wind data has been operational at the Deutscher Wetterdienst, with a diagonal observation error (OE) covariance matrix. For an implementation of a full OE covariance matrix, the statistics of the OE have to be a priori estimated, for which the Desroziers method has been often used. However, the resulted statistics consists of contributions from different error sources and are difficult to interpret. In this work, we use an approach that is based on samples for truncation error in radar observation space to approximate the representation error due to unresolved scales and processes (RE) and compare its statistics with the OE statistics estimated by the Desroziers method. It is found that the statistics of the RE help the understanding of several important features in the variances and correlation length scales of the OE for both reflectivity and radial wind data and the other error sources from the microphysical scheme, radar observation operator and the superobbing technique may also contribute, for instance, to differences among different elevations and observation types. The statistics presented here can serve as a guideline for selecting which observations are assimilated and for assignment of the OE covariance matrix that can be diagonal or full and correlated.
19 October 2021 in Journal of Advances in Modeling Earth Systems
For convective clouds and precipitation, model uncertainty in cloud microphysics is considered one of the most significant sources of model error. In this study, samples for model microphysical uncertainty are obtained by calculating the differences between simulations equipped with two‐ and one‐moment schemes during a one‐month training period. The samples are then added to convective‐scale ensemble data assimilation as additive noise and combined with large‐scale additive noise based on samples from climatological atmospheric background error covariance. Two experiments, including the combination and large‐scale error only, are conducted for a one‐week convective period. The results reveal that the simulation with a two‐moment scheme triggers more convection and has larger ice‐phase precipitation particles, which produce a stronger signal in the melting layer. During data assimilation cycling, although more water is introduced to the model, it is shown that the combination performs better for both background and analysis and significantly improves short‐term ensemble forecasts of radar reflectivity and hourly precipitation.
In order to further investigate the influence of ensemble generation methods on the storm-scale ensemble forecast (SSEF) system, a new ensemble sensitivity analysis-based ensemble transform with 3D rescaling (ET_3DR_ESA) method was developed. The Weather Research and Forecasting (WRF) Model was used to numerically simulate a squall line that occurred in the Jianghuai region in China on 12 July 2014. In this study, initial perturbations were generated via ET_3DR_ESA, and the ensemble forecast performance was compared to that of the dynamical downscaling (Down) method and the ensemble transform with 3D rescaling (ET_3DR) method. Results from a set of experiments indicate that ET_3DR_ESA linked to multi-scale environmental fields generates initial perturbations that can not only capture analysis uncertainties, but also match the actual synoptic conditions. Such perturbations produce faster ensemble spread growth, lower root-mean-square error, and a lower percentage of outliers, especially during the peak period of the squall line. In addition, ET_3DR_ESA can effectively reduce the energy dissipation on different scales through the analysis of the power spectrum. Moreover, the intensity and distribution forecasts of heavy rainfall from the ET_3DR_ESA ensemble forecast system were demonstrated to better match the observation. Furthermore, according to results of the relative operating characteristic (ROC) test, Brier score (BS), and equitable threat score (ETS), ET_3DR_ESA significantly improved the forecast skills for heavy rain (15–30 mm/12 h) and extreme rain (>30 mm/12 h), which are critical to the realization of accurate storm-scale system precipitation forecasts. In general, these results suggest that ET_3DR_ESA can be effectively applied to SSEF systems.
In the present work, we investigate the impacts on the observation error (OE) statistics due to different types of errors in the forward operator (FE) for both radar reflectivity and radial wind data, in the context of convective-scale data assimilation in the summertime. A series of sensitivity experiments were conducted with the Efficient Modular VOlume RADar Operator (EMVORADO), using the operational data assimilation system of the Deutscher Wetterdienst (DWD, German Weather Service). The investigated FEs are versatile, including errors caused by neglecting the terminal fall speed of hydrometeor, the reflectivity weighting, and the beam broadening and attenuation effects, as well as errors caused by different scattering schemes and formulations for melting particles. For reflectivity, it is found that accounting for the beam broadening effect evidently reduces the standard deviations, especially at higher altitudes. However, it does not shorten the horizontal or along-beam correlation length scales. In comparison between the Rayleigh and the Mie schemes (with specific configurations), the former one results in much smaller standard deviations for heights up to 4 km, and aloft, slightly larger standard deviations. Imposing the attenuation to the Mie scheme slightly reduces the standard deviations at lower altitudes; however, it largely increases the standard deviations at higher altitudes and it also leads to longer correlation length scales. For radial wind, positive impacts of considering the beam broadening effect on standard deviations and neutral impacts on correlations are observed. For both reflectivity and radial wind, taking the terminal fall speed of hydrometeor and the reflectivity weighting into account does not make remarkable differences in the estimated OE statistics.
Radar data assimilation has been operational at the Deutscher Wetterdienst for several years and is essential for generating accurate precipitation forecasts. The current work attempts to further enhance the radar data assimilation by improving the latent heat nudging (LHN) scheme and by reducing the observation error (OE) caused by the representation error of the efficient modular volume radar operator (EMVORADO). First of all, a series of hindcasts for a one-month convective period over Germany are performed. Compared with radar reflectivity and satellite observations, it is found that the LHN scheme that implicitly adjusts temperature performs better, and the beam broadening effect and the choice of the scattering schemes in EMVORADO are important. Moreover, the Mie scheme with the new parameterization to reduce the brightband effect not only proves to be the best in hindcasts but also that it results in the smallest standard deviations and the shortest horizontal correlation length scales of the OE in data assimilation experiments.
Assimilation of weather radar measurements including radar reflectivity and radial wind data has been operational at the Deutscher Wetterdienst, with a diagonal observation error (OE) covariance matrix. For an implementation of a full OE covariance matrix, the statistics of the OE have to be a priori estimated, for which the Desroziers method has been often used. However, the resulted statistics consists of contributions from different error sources and are difficult to interpret. In this work, we use an approach that is based on samples for truncation error in radar observation space to approximate the representation error due to unresolved scales and processes (RE) and compare its statistics with the OE statistics estimated by the Desroziers method. It is found that the statistics of the RE help the understanding of several important features in the variances and correlation length scales of the OE for both reflectivity and radial wind data and the other error sources from the microphysical scheme, radar observation operator and the superobbing technique may also contribute, for instance, to differences among different elevations and observation types. The statistics presented here can serve as a guideline for selecting which observations to assimilate and for assignment of the OE covariance matrix that can be diagonal or full and correlated.