Visually black, electrically leaky, amorphous titania (am-TiO₂) thin films were grown by atomic layer deposition (ALD) for photocatalytic applications. Broad spectral absorbance in the visible range and exceptional conductivity are attributed to trapped Ti³⁺ in the film. Oxidation of Ti³⁺ upon heat treatment leads to a drop in conductivity, a color change from black to white and crystallization of am-TiO₂. ALD grown black TiO₂, without any heat treatment, is subject to dissolution in alkaline photoelectrochemical conditions. The best photocatalytic activity for solar water splitting is obtained for completely crystalline white TiO₂.