The remarkable morphological disparity of the animal kingdom is underpinned by changes in embryonic development across the tree of life; as such, deciphering evolutionary patterns of developmental divergence depends on investigations of different species across a range of comparable developmental stages. Among the most influential ideas regarding such developmental divergences are von Baer’s Laws of Development and Haeckel’s Theory of Recapitulation. Here, we assess several predictions following from these ideas at the tissue-level by comparing skull osteogenesis in representatives of the bird clade Galloanserae. We investigated high-resolution µCT scans of embryonic series for four galloanseran species: chickens and quails, representing Galliformes (landfowl), and ducks and geese, representing Anseriformes (waterfowl). To compare skull osteogenesis across our taxon sample, we devised a skull-specific staging system based on ossification sequences to discretise the process into five stages. During skull osteogenesis, we found that the location of the onset of ossification within each element and the direction of ossification progression were the same in all species in our sample, implying a conserved developmental programme for induction and ossification progression across Galloanserae. Moreover, we found that the appearance of synapomorphies diagnostic of broader clades often overlapped with species-specific ones during osteogenesis. Indeed, many diagnostic features of deep clades, such as osteological synapomorphies of the phylogenetically inclusive clade Galloanserae, appear at surprisingly late stages of development. These observations fail to support several predictions of von Baer’s Laws of Development and Haeckel’s Theory of Recapitulation, instead suggesting what we term a ‘braiding’ pattern of developmental divergence in which degrees of interspecific morphological similarity wax and wane during development as a result of the interplay between developmental constraints and phyletic variation.
Studying avian embryology necessitates reliable and precise staging tables—descriptions of embryonic features appearing during development that are used to approximate the extent of embryonic development from fertilisation to hatching. Staging tables for waterfowl (Anseriformes) have previously been established based on morphological features from fertilisation to approximately 10 days before hatching. Embryonic changes over the final 10 days of pre‐hatching development have also been documented and proposed as useful staging criteria. However, the reliability of these changes—which focus on the size of the bill and middle toes—as useful staging criteria across different waterfowl breeds has not been fully examined. To evaluate the reliability of these criteria for staging near‐hatching embryos, we examined 27 embryos of Mallard ( Anas platyrhynchos ) and Swan Goose ( Anser cygnoides ). Comparisons with previously published data revealed that size variation within the same developmental stage across breeds is equivalent to within‐breed variation across different stages, suggesting limited reliability of bill and middle toe size for staging waterfowl embryos. Consequently, we devised novel staging criteria for waterfowl based on four easily measurable morphological traits and show that these criteria allow correct stage identification with over 70% accuracy. Our results highlight the importance of quantifying staging accuracy for improving the reliability of embryonic staging tables.
Anseriformes (waterfowl) and Galliformes (landfowl) are among the world most recognisable groups of birds, together comprising the clade Galloanserae. Despite their close evolutionary relationship, the skulls of adult anseriforms and galliforms exhibit strikingly distinct morphologies, the developmental basis and evolutionary history of which is poorly understood. To illuminate the developmental and evolutionary underpinnings of cranial disparity between and within these major extant bird clades, we quantitatively investigated ontogenetic changes in cranial morphology across galloanseran phylogenetic diversity, focusing on the previously unexplored post-hatching interval during which adult morphology takes shape. Our results reveal the combined effects of multiple heterochronic shifts early in galloanseran evolutionary history including anseriform hypermorphosis, along with influential nonheterochronic changes leading to substantially more disparate ontogenetic trajectories, and greater cranial variability, in anseriforms than galliforms. Key galloanseran fossils help clarify the polarity of evolutionary shifts in cranial development through galloanseran phylogenetic history and demonstrate that extant galliform cranial morphology is more constrained and retains a more plesiomorphic morphology than that of anseriforms. Our work helps illuminate the developmental basis of the iconic differences in cranial form between waterfowl and landfowl and illustrates the importance of broad phylogenetic and ontogenetic sampling for clarifying patterns of post-hatching developmental divergence among major vertebrate clades.
Studying waterfowl embryology necessitates reliable and precise staging tables. These are descriptions of embryonic features throughout development from fertilisation to hatching stage, which are used to approximate the extent of embryonic development. Waterfowl staging tables have previously been established based on morphological features from fertilisation to approximately ten days before hatching. Embryonic changes over the final ten days of pre-hatching development have also been documented and proposed as useful staging criteria. However, the reliability of these changes as useful staging criteria across different waterfowl breeds has not been fully examined. To examine the reliability of these criteria, which focus on size changes of the bill and middle toes, for staging near-hatching embryos, we examined twenty-seven Mallard and Swan Geese embryos and measured their beak and toe-length sizes. We compared our results with previously published data, and found that size variation across breeds within the same developmental stage is equivalent to within-breed variation across different stages, suggesting limited reliability of beak and middle toe length sizes for staging waterfowl embryos. Consequently, we devised novel staging criteria for waterfowl based on four easily measurable morphological traits and show that these criteria allow correct stage identification with over 70% accuracy. Our results highlight the importance of quantifying accuracy for developing reliable embryonic staging tables.