Barry G. Hankin

Barry G. Hankin

orcid

Research Focus & Metrics

Academic Career Length

25Years (2002-Present)

(Calculated once Scilit publication data is synced: current year − year of first publication + 1)

Representative Publications

View All Publications
27 April 2018 in Hydrology and Earth System Sciences
Verified
Journal Article
Open access
PDF file
PMPeter Metcalfe
Peter Metcalfe
KBKeith Beven
Keith Beven
BHBarry G. Hankin
Barry G. Hankin
RLRob Lamb
Rob Lamb
Enhanced hillslope storage is utilised in “natural” flood management in order to retain overland storm run-off and to reduce connectivity between fast surface flow pathways and the channel. Examples include excavated ponds, deepened or bunded accumulation areas, and gullies and ephemeral channels blocked with wooden barriers or debris dams. The performance of large, distributed networks of such measures is poorly understood. Extensive schemes can potentially retain large quantities of run-off, but there are indications that much of their effectiveness can be attributed to desynchronisation of sub-catchment flood waves. Inappropriately sited measures may therefore increase, rather than mitigate, flood risk. Fully distributed hydrodynamic models have been applied in limited studies but introduce significant computational complexity. The longer run times of such models also restrict their use for uncertainty estimation or evaluation of the many potential configurations and storm sequences that may influence the timings and magnitudes of flood waves. Here a simplified overland flow-routing module and semi-distributed representation of enhanced hillslope storage is developed. It is applied to the headwaters of a large rural catchment in Cumbria, UK, where the use of an extensive network of storage features is proposed as a flood mitigation strategy. The models were run within a Monte Carlo framework against data for a 2-month period of extreme flood events that caused significant damage in areas downstream. Acceptable realisations and likelihood weightings were identified using the GLUE uncertainty estimation framework. Behavioural realisations were rerun against the catchment model modified with the addition of the hillslope storage. Three different drainage rate parameters were applied across the network of hillslope storage. The study demonstrates that schemes comprising widely distributed hillslope storage can be modelled effectively within such a reduced complexity framework. It shows the importance of drainage rates from storage features while operating through a sequence of events. We discuss limitations in the simplified representation of overland flow-routing and representation and storage, and how this could be improved using experimental evidence. We suggest ways in which features could be grouped more strategically and thus improve the performance of such schemes.

1 October 2020 in Natural Hazards and Earth System Sciences
Verified
Journal Article
Open access
PDF file
BHBarry G. Hankin
Barry G. Hankin
IHIan Hewitt
Ian Hewitt
GSGraham Sander
Graham Sander
FDFederico Danieli
Federico Danieli
GFGiuseppe Formetta
Giuseppe Formetta
RLRob Lamb
Rob Lamb
We develop a network-based model of a catchment basin that incorporates the possibility of small-scale, in-channel, leaky barriers as flood attenuation features, on each of the edges of the network. The model can be used to understand effective risk reduction strategies considering the whole-system performance; here we focus on identifying network dam placements promoting effective dynamic utilisation of storage and placements that also reduce risk of breach or cascade failure of dams during high flows. We first demonstrate the model using idealised networks and explore risk of cascade failure using probabilistic barrier-fragility assumptions. The investigation highlights the need for robust design of nature-based measures, to avoid inadvertent exposure of communities to a flood risk, and we conclude that the principle of building the leaky barriers on the upstream tributaries is generally less risky than building on the main trunk, although this may depend on the network structure specific to the catchment under study. The efficient scheme permits rapid assessment of the whole-system performance of dams placed in different locations in real networks, demonstrated in application to a real system of leaky barriers built in Penny Gill, a stream in the West Cumbria region of Britain.

11 October 2022 in Hydrological Processes
Verified
Journal Article
Open access
KBKeith Beven
Keith Beven
SLStuart Lane
Stuart Lane
TPTrevor Page
Trevor Page
AKAnn Kretzschmar
Ann Kretzschmar
BHBarry G. Hankin
Barry G. Hankin
NCNick Chappell
Nick Chappell
Part 1 of this study discussed the concept of using a form of Turing‐like test for model evaluation, together with eight principles for implementing such an approach. In this part, the framing of fitness‐for‐purpose as a Turing‐like test is discussed, together with an example application of trying to assess whether a rainfall‐runoff model might be an adequate representation of the discharge response in a catchment for predicting future natural flood management scenarios. It is shown that the variation between event runoff coefficients in the record can be used to create some limits of acceptability that implicitly take some account of the epistemic uncertainties arising from lack of knowledge about errors in rainfall and discharge observations. In the case study it is demonstrated that the model used cannot be validated in this way across all the range of observed discharges, but that behavioural models can be found for the peak flows that are the subject of interest in the application. Thinking in terms of the Turing‐like test focusses attention on the critical observations needed to test whether streamflow is being produced in the right way so that a model is considered as fit‐for‐purpose in predicting the impacts of future change scenarios. As is the case for uncertainty estimation in general, it is argued that the assumptions made in setting behavioural limits of acceptability should be stated explicitly to leave an audit trail in any application that can be reviewed by users of the model outputs.

11 August 2020 in Journal of Flood Risk Management
Verified
Journal Article
Open access
PDF file
RTRoss Towe
Ross Towe
GDGraham Dean
Graham Dean
LELiz Edwards
Liz Edwards
VNVatsala Nundloll
Vatsala Nundloll
GBGordon Blair
Gordon Blair
SMSusan Manson
Susan Manson
Decision‐making in flood risk management is increasingly dependent on access to data, with the availability of data increasing dramatically in recent years. We are therefore moving towards an era of big data, with the added challenges that, in this area, data sources are highly heterogeneous, at a variety of scales, and include a mix of structured and unstructured data. The key requirement is therefore one of integration and subsequent analyses of this complex web of data. This paper examines the potential of a data‐driven approach to support decision‐making in flood risk management, with the goal of investigating a suitable software architecture and associated set of techniques to support a more data‐centric approach. The key contribution of the paper is a cloud‐based data hypercube that achieves the desired level of integration of highly complex data. This hypercube builds on innovations in cloud services for data storage, semantic enrichment and querying, and also features the use of notebook technologies to support open and collaborative scenario analyses in support of decision making. The paper also highlights the success of our agile methodology in weaving together cross‐disciplinary perspectives and in engaging a wide range of stakeholders in exploring possible technological futures for flood risk management.

26 October 2021 in Hydrological Processes
Verified
Journal Article
Open access
PDF file
BHBarry G. Hankin
Barry G. Hankin
TPTrevor J. C. Page
Trevor J. C. Page
NCNick A. Chappell
Nick A. Chappell
KBKeith J. Beven
Keith J. Beven
PSPaul J. Smith
Paul J. Smith
RLRob Lamb
Rob Lamb
The Q‐natural flood management project has co‐developed with the Environment Agency 18 monitored micro‐catchments (~1 km2) in Cumbria, UK installing calibrated flumes aimed at quantifying the potential shift in observed flows resulting from a range of nature‐based‐solutions installed by local organizations. The small‐scale reduces the influence of variability characterizing larger catchments that would otherwise mask any such shifts, which we attempt to relate to a shift in model parameters. This paper demonstrates an approach to applying donor‐parameter‐shifts obtained from modelling two of the paired micro‐catchments to a much larger scale, in order to understand the potential for improved distributed modelling of nature‐based solutions in the form of additional tree‐planting. The models include a rainfall‐runoff model, Dynamic Topmodel, and a 2D hydrodynamic model, JFlow, permitting analysis of changes in hillslope processes and channel hydrodynamics resulting from a range of distributed measures designed to emulate natural hydrological processes that evaporate, store or infiltrate flows. We report on attempts to detect shift in hydrological response using one of the paired‐micro‐catchment moorland versus forestry sites in Lorton using Dynamic Topmodel. A donor‐parameter‐shift approach is used in a hypothetical experiment to represent new woodland in a much larger catchment, although testing all combinations of spatial planting strategies, responses to multiple‐extremes, failure‐modes and changes to synchronization becomes intractable to support good decision making. We argue that the problem can be re‐framed to use donor‐parameter‐shifts at multi‐local‐scale catchments above communities known to be at risk, commensurate with most of the evidence of NbS impacts being effective at the small scale (ca. 10 km2). This might lead to more effective modelling to help catchment managers prioritize those communities‐at‐risk where there is more evidence that NbS might be effective.

24 November 2022 in Hydrological Processes
Verified
Journal Article
Open access
TPTrevor Page
Trevor Page
KBKeith J. Beven
Keith J. Beven
BHBarry G. Hankin
Barry G. Hankin
NCNick A. Chappell
Nick A. Chappell
The representation of rainfall in space is important for hydrological modelling. Accurate estimation of rainfall is particularly challenging in mountainous regions where observations are often sparse relative to the spatial variability of rainfall. In these regions, orographic processes lead to complex patterns of rainfall enhancement and rain shadow depletion. This study testsNatural Neighbour Interpolation (NNI),ordinary kriging (OK)andordinary cokriging (CK), to determine ifCKimproves rainfall interpolation during three extreme rainfall events. Three different elevation indices were considered as secondary variables forCK. Preliminary analysis using long‐term annual average rainfall totals, including additional high elevation rainfall observations, showed thatCKwith an effective elevation index (a directionally smoothed elevation, corrected for degree of ‘orographic processing’ and shifted to account for ‘wind‐drift’ of rainfall) as a secondary variable performed better thanNNIandOKwith an overall improvement of around 40%. Using rainfall totals for long‐term wind direction and wind speed rainfall classes,CKperformance was variable but provided an improvement of approximately 15% for wind direction classeswithoutan easterly wind component. For 15‐min timesteps during extreme rainfall events, there were comparatively small differences (cross‐validation usingRMSE) between interpolation methods, partly attributed to having only relatively low elevation rainfall observations, providing weak constraint. Using cross‐validation andmean biasdid, however, show an improvement for both high and low elevation observation classes. Importantly, cross‐variogram estimation provided differing cross‐validation results when estimated for different rainfall accumulation periods: 15‐min, hourly, daily and long‐term. Variograms and cross variograms estimated at a 15‐min timestep frequency were robust for many timesteps, but were difficult to fit automatically for others. Variograms estimated from longer periods were more reliably estimated, but tended to have lower variance and cross‐variance and longer correlation ranges producing a smoother interpolated rainfall field. Given the weak cross‐validation constraint, care must be taken in identifying the most appropriate method and variogram estimation period.