The Annualised Agricultural Non-point Source model was used to evaluate the effectiveness of different management practices to control the soil erosion and sediment load in the Carapelle watershed, a Mediterranean medium-size watershed (506 km2) located in Apulia, Southern Italy. The model was previously calibrated and validated using five years of runoff and sediment load data measured at a monitoring station located at Ordona - Ponte dei Sauri Bridge. A total of 36 events were used to estimate the performance of the model during the period 2007-2011. The model performed well in predicting runoff, as the high values of the coefficients of efficiency and determination during the validation process showed. The peak flows predictions were satisfactory especially for the high flow events; the prediction capability of sediment load was good, even if a slight over-estimation was observed. Simulations of alternative management practices show that converting the most eroding cropland cells (13.5% of the catchment area) to no tillage would reduce soil erosion by 30%, while converting them to grass or forest would reduce soil erosion by 36.5% in both cases. A crop rotation of wheat and a forage crop can also provide an effective way for soil erosion control as it reduces erosion by 69%. Those results can provide a good comparative analysis for conservation planners to choose the best scenarios to be adopted in the watershed to achieve goals in terms of soil conservation and water quality.
The Annualized Agricultural Non-point Source (AnnAGNPS) model can be used to analyze the effects of management practices on sediment loads in agricultural watersheds. The study was performed in a 506 km2 Mediterranean watershed located in Apulia, Southern Italy, planted with mostly winter wheat (83%) where runoff and sediment loads have been monitored at an in-stream gage. The AnnAGNPS model was used to predict runoff and sediment load without calibration during a 5-year period. On an annual scale, the model showed good prediction capability for runoff (R2 = 0.8, NSE [Nash and Sutcliffe coefficient of efficiency] = 0.7) and satisfactory results for sediment load (NSE = 0.5, R2 = 0.5). Based on the current conditions of the watershed as a baseline scenario, the effectiveness of alternative conservation practices applied within the watershed was also evaluated. No-tillage practices applied to the entire cropland area reduced soil erosion within fields by 44% and sediment yield from fields to streams by 20%. Reduced tillage decreased soil erosion, sediment yield, and sediment load at the gage location by 12%, 7%, and 4% respectively. Limiting the placement of alternative practices to the cropland sub-watersheds with the most erosion (Scenarios G and H) proved to be a promising and viable approach to sediment erosion reduction throughout the watershed. In this perspective, areas that produce the most sediment were identified and targeted for replacement of varying levels of cropland with forest, and consequently sediment loads were reduced from 5% to 97%. The effect of vegetated streams and riparian buffers as natural traps that can increase the in situ sediment deposition was also considered. Most, but not all of the scenarios discussed herein could realistically be implemented within the watershed, particularly if there are incentive policies. Even considering the intrinsic uncertainty of modeling results, evaluating these systems with the aid of AnnAGNPS serves as a means to provide reference information and allows watershed conservation planners to compare the impacts of different management scenarios with sustainable agriculture guidelines.
This paper explores the potential implementation of Nature-Based Solutions (NBSs) in agriculture, specifically focusing on soil and water management in Southern Italy, particularly in the Apulia and Basilicata regions. Through a tailored questionnaire, it investigates farmers’ perceptions of the utility of NBSs, addressing key issues in the region and evaluating their role in addressing soil and water management challenges. Findings reveal primary challenges such as drought, floods, and water pollution, with soil erosion being a major concern. Several NBSs, including wetlands and bioswales, demonstrate consistent utility and performance, while disparities exist for agroforestry and strip cropping. The study underscores a significant gap in the economic valuation of NBSs, emphasizing the need for comprehensive assessments that incorporate livability improvements, water quality enhancement, and socio-cultural benefits. Additionally, an analysis of NBS implementation across Italian agriculture reveals limited case studies, suggesting the need for strategic expansions to meet Sustainable Development Goals. This research offers critical insights into the effectiveness and challenges of NBSs in agricultural soil and water management, advocating for enhanced stakeholder engagement and the development of multidimensional evaluation frameworks to support sustainable practices.