Evaluation of the impact of turbidity on satellite-derived bathymetry (SDB) is a crucial step for selecting optimal scenes and for addressing the limitations of SDB. This study examines the relatively high-resolution MultiSpectral instrument (MSI) onboard Sentinel-2A (10–20–60 m) and the moderate-resolution Ocean and Land Color instrument (OLCI) onboard Sentinel-3A (300 m) for generating bathymetric maps through a conventional ratio transform model in environments with some turbidity in South Florida. Both sensors incorporate additional spectral bands in the red-edge near infrared (NIR) region, allowing turbidity detection in optically shallow waters. The ratio model only requires two calibration parameters for vertical referencing using available chart data, whereas independent lidar surveys are used for validation and error analysis. The MSI retrieves bathymetry at 10 m with errors of 0.58 m at depths ranging between 0–18 m (limit of lidar survey) in West Palm Beach and of 0.22 m at depths ranging between 0–5 m in Key West, in conditions with low turbidity. In addition, this research presents an assessment of the SDB depth limit caused by turbidity as determined with the reflectance of the red-edge bands at 709 nm (OLCI) and 704 nm (MSI) and a standard ocean color chlorophyll concentration. OLCI and MSI results are comparable, indicating the potential of the two optical missions as interchangeable sensors that can help determine the selection of the optimal scenes for SDB mapping. OLCI can provide temporal data to identify water quality characteristics and general SDB patterns. The relationship of turbidity with depth detection may help to enhance the operational use of SDB over environments with varying water transparency conditions, particularly in remote and inaccessible regions of the world.
Satellite imagery has been used to monitor and assess Harmful Algal Blooms (HABs), specifically, cyanobacterial blooms in Lake Erie (the USA and Canada) for over twelve years. In recent years, imagery has been applied to the other Great Lakes as well as other U.S. lakes. The key algorithm used in this monitoring system is the cyanobacterial index (CI), a measure of the chlorophyll found in cyanobacterial blooms. The CI is a “spectral shape” (or curvature) algorithm, which is a form of the second derivative around the 681 nm (MERIS/OLCI) or 678 nm (MODIS) band, which is robust and implicitly includes an atmospheric correction, allowing reliable use for many more scenes than analytical algorithms. Monitoring of cyanobacterial blooms with the CI began with the European Space Agency’s (ESA) Medium Resolution Imaging Spectrometer (MERIS) sensor (2002–2012). With the loss of data from MERIS in the spring of 2012, the monitoring system shifted to using NASA’s Moderate Resolution Imaging Spectroradiometer (MODIS). MODIS has bands that allow computation of a CI product, which was intercalibrated with MERIS at the time to establish a conversion of MODIS CI to MERIS CI. In 2016, ESA launched the Ocean and Land Color Imager (OLCI), the replacement for MERIS, on the Sentinel-3 spacecraft. MODIS can serve two purposes. It can provide a critical data set for the blooms of 2012–2015, and it offers a bridge from MERIS to OLCI. We propose a basin-wide integrated technique for intercalibrating the CI algorithm from MODIS to both MERIS and OLCI. This method allowed us to intercalibrate OLCI CI to MERIS CI, which would then allow the production of a 20-year and ongoing record of cyanobacterial bloom activity. This approach also allows updates as sensor calibrations change or new sensors are launched, and it could be readily applied to spectral shape algorithms.
This manuscript describes methods for evaluating the efficacy of five satellite-based Chlorophyll-a algorithms in Chesapeake Bay, spanning three separate sensors: Ocean Land Color Imager (OLCI), Visible Infrared Imaging Radiometer Suite (VIIRS), and MODerate Resolution Imaging Spectroradiometer (MODIS). The algorithms were compared using in situ Chlorophyll-a measurements from 38 separate stations, provided through the Chesapeake Bay Program (CBP). These stations span nearly the entire 300 km length of the optically complex Chesapeake Bay, the largest estuary in the United States. Overall accuracy was examined for the entire dataset, in addition to assessing the differences related to the distance from the turbidity maximum to the north by grouping the results into the upper bay, middle bay, or lower bay. The mean bias and the Mean Absolute Error (MAE) as well as the median bias and Median Absolute Error (MedAE) were conducted for comparison. A two-band algorithm, that is based on the red-edge portion of the electromagnetic spectrum (RE10), when applied to OLCI imagery, exhibited the lowest overall MedAE of 36% at all stations. As a result, it is recommended that the RE10 algorithm be applied to OLCI and provided as an operational product through NOAA’s CoastWatch program. The paper will conclude with results from a brief climatological analysis using the OLCI RE10 algorithm.
Satellite-based monitoring of cyanobacterial harmful algal blooms (CyanoHABs) heavily utilizes historical Envisat-MERIS and current Sentinel-OLCI observations due to the availability of the 620 nm and 709 nm bands. The permanent loss of communication with Envisat in April 2012 created an observational gap from 2012 until the operationalization of OLCI in 2016. Although MODIS-Terra has been used to bridge the gap from 2012 to 2015, differences in band architecture and the absence of the 709 nm band have complicated generating a consistent and continuous CyanoHAB monitoring product. Moreover, several Terra bands often saturate during extreme high-concentration CyanoHAB events. This study trained a fully connected deep network (CyanNet) to model MERIS-Cyanobacteria Index (CI)—a key satellite algorithm for detecting and quantifying cyanobacteria. The network was trained with Rayleigh-corrected surface reflectance at 12 Terra bands from 2002–2008, 2010–2012, and 2017–2021 and validated with data from 2009 and 2016 in Lake Okeechobee. Model performance was satisfactory, with a ~17% median difference in Lake Okeechobee annual bloom magnitude. The median difference was ~36% with 10-day Chlorophyll-a time series data, with differences often due to variations in data availability, clouds or glint. Without further regional training, the same network performed well in Lake Apopka, Lake George, and western Lake Erie. Validation success, especially in Lake Erie, shows the generalizability of CyanNet and transferability to other geographic regions.