Frequency downshift (FD) in wave trains on deep water occurs when a measure of the frequency, typically the spectral peak or the spectral mean, decreases as the waves evolve. Many FD models rely on wind or wave breaking. We consider seven models that do not include these effects and compare their predictions with four sets of experiments that also do not include these effects. The models are the (i) nonlinear Schrödinger equation (NLS), (ii) dissipative NLS equation (dNLS), (iii) Dysthe equation, (iv) viscous Dysthe equation (vDysthe), (v) Gordon equation (Gordon), which has a free parameter, (vi) Islas-Schober equation (IS), which has a free parameter, and (vii) a new model, the dissipative Gramstad-Trulsen (dGT) equation. The dGT equation has no free parameters and addresses some of the difficulties associated with the vDysthe equation. We compare a measure of overall error and the evolution of the spectral amplitudes, means, and peaks. We find the following: (i) The NLS and Dysthe equations do not accurately predict the spectral amplitudes. (ii) The Gordon equation, which is a successful model of FD in optics, does not accurately model FD in water waves, regardless of the choice of free parameter. (iii) The dNLS, vDysthe, dGT, and IS (with optimized free parameter) models do a reasonable job predicting the measured spectral amplitudes, but none captures all spectral evolutions. (iv) The vDysthe, dGT, and IS models most accurately predict the observed evolution of the spectral peak and the spectral mean. (v) The IS and vDysthe models have the smallest overall errors.
The two-dimensional cubic nonlinear Schrödinger equation (NLS) can be used as a model of phenomena in physical systems ranging from waves on deep water to pulses in optical fibers. In this paper, we establish that every one-dimensional traveling wave solution of NLS with linear phase is unstable with respect to some infinitesimal perturbation with two-dimensional structure. If the coefficients of the linear dispersion terms have the same sign (elliptic case), then the only unstable perturbations have transverse wavelength longer than a well-defined cutoff. If the coefficients of the linear dispersion terms have opposite signs (hyperbolic case), then there is no such cutoff and as the wavelength decreases, the maximum growth rate approaches a well-defined limit.
1 November 1993 in Journal of the American Chemical Society
Recently, the Whitham and capillary Whitham equations were shown to accurately model the evolution of surface waves on shallow water. In order to gain a deeper understanding of these equations, we compute periodic, traveling-wave solutions for both and study their stability. We present plots of a representative sampling of solutions for a range of wavelengths, wave speeds, wave heights, and surface tension values. Finally, we discuss the role these parameters play in the stability of these solutions.