Sampling fish by trapping can lead to biased conclusions about a population. We used catch data to assess differences between two types of traps for adult sea lamprey (Petromyzon marinus), submerged-funnel traps and studded-tile traps, which are angled ramps with trickle flow leading out of the water. The studded-tile trap at one river caught about 50% more females than the funnel trap. It caught males that had a smaller body size and females with a lower gonado-somatic index (GSI). The likelihood of catching lamprey in the studded-tile trap increased after they had been caught once. This was not the case for the funnel traps, which are used for mark–recapture-based population assessment of invasive sea lamprey in the Great Lakes. The apparent trap response caused by studded-tile traps may have been caused by a behavioral bias, i.e., the traps consistently attracting a subset of the population. Use of the studded-tile trap for population assessment should only be considered after more is known about its recapture bias. The differences between lamprey caught in the two trap types suggests that a variety of trapping methods needs to be employed in order to get a representative sample from a fish population.
Most artificial fishways allow upstream passage of large-bodied, strong-swimming fish species. Wetted ramps, which are moderate in inclination and have little water flow, could allow passage of smaller-bodied fishes over low-head dams and culverts. We observed creek chubs (Semotilus atromculatus) and white suckers (Catostomus commersonii) on wetted ramps in a laboratory setting. Smaller individuals entered the ramps at lower absolute swim velocities but exhibited superior upstream passage due to positive acceleration in the thin (<1 cm) water layer on the ramps. Larger fish displayed more pronounced, probably less efficient, head and tail amplitudes during passage. We argue that the relatively smaller depth of immersion in water was responsible for hampering the larger-bodied individuals on the ramps. Warmer water temperatures (15 °C vs. 10 °C) roughly doubled the mean distance fish traveled up the ramps. Our findings can inform fishway design for small-bodied fishes. In regions with low-head barriers against invasive sea lamprey (Petromyzon marinus), wetted ramps may help connect habitats for native fish species.
Dams fragment stream habitats and fishways around dams typically serve few species that are strong swimmers or jumpers. We tested a prototype wetted ramp designed to allow upstream passage of small-bodied fishes while blocking upstream movement of invasive sea lampreys in the Laurentian Great Lakes. We tested short, smooth ramps with 5–10 mm water depth in various combinations of ramp angle, water flow, and swim channel width with the aim to selectively block adult migrating sea lampreys (Petromyzon marinus) while passing sub-adult white suckers (Catostomus commersonii) and creek chubs (Semotilus atromaculatus). Sea lampreys easily passed a 0.75 ramp at a 5° angle, but very few individuals passed a similar ramp at a 10° angle, and none passed a longer ramp at a 5° angle. Limiting the amplitude of tailbeats in a narrow channel did not hamper lampreys or the other species. Greater water flow, and thereby greater immersion depth on the ramp, fostered passage for all species. Smaller-bodied individuals of creek chubs and white suckers performed best on the ramp. We showed that wetted ramps could be incorporated into fishways at low-head dams to aid the passage of smaller-bodied fishes while also blocking the spawning migration of adult sea lampreys.
Dams fragment stream habitat and fishways around dams typically serve few species that are strong swimmers or jumpers. We test a prototype wetted ramp designed to allow upstream passage of small-bodied fishes while blocking upstream movement of invasive sea lamprey in the Laurentian Great Lakes. We tested short, smooth ramps with 5-10 mm water depth in various combinations of ramp angle, water flow and swim channel width with the aim to selectively block adult migrating sea lamprey while passing sub-adult white suckers (Catostomus commersonii) and creek chubs (Semotilus atromaculatus). Sea lamprey easily passed a 0.75 ramp at 5 angle, but very few individuals passed a similar ramp at 10 angle and none passed a longer ramp at the 5 angle. Limiting the amplitude of tailbeats in a narrow channel did not hamper lamprey or the other species. Greater water flow, and thereby greater immersion depth on the ramp fostered passage for all species. Smaller-bodied individual of creek chubs and white suckers performed best on the ramp. We show that wetted ramps could be incorporated into fishways at low-head dams to aid passage of smaller-bodied fishes while also blocking the spawning migration of adult sea lamprey.