The dominant approach to evaluating distributional features of ordinal variables (e.g. self-reported health status) has been the Allison-Foster bipolarization ordering (henceforth AF). It has not yet been extended to a multidimensional setting. Here we fill this gap. A multidimensional extension of the AF relation is characterized by a sequence of median-preserving spreads on each dimension and association-changing switches. This extension does not pay attention to the dimensions’ association. We then offer one that does and characterize it in terms of classes of polarization measures and welfare functions. Based on these two orderings we construct polarization indices and develop statistical inference for them. We measure bidimensional polarization in educational attainment and life satisfaction across OECD members. Dependence does not affect whether or not countries dominate each other bidimensionally.
25 September 2018 in Economics of Education Review
Theoretical literature on whether school competition raises public school productivity is ambiguous (e.g. MacLeod & Urquiola, 2015) and empirical evidence is mixed (e.g. Hsieh and Urquiola, 2006). Moreover, competition might itself be an outcome of changes in productivity (e.g. Hoxby, 2003). We provide evidence for the negative effect of the threat of competition on students’ test scores in elementary public schools in Poland. The identification strategy uses the introduction of the amendment facilitating the creation of autonomous schools in Poland in 2009 as an external shock to the threat of competition. We focus on the short run in which there is only a limited set of actions available to schools’ principals. For the total sample we find no effect, however, for more competitive urban educational markets, we report a drop in test scores in public schools following the increased threat of competition. This negative effect is robust to the existence of autonomous schools prior to the amendment and to the size of public schools. It does not result from a pre-existing or concurrent trend either. We exclude student sorting and adjustments in schools’ expenditures as potential channels.
1 December 2018 in Journal of Mathematical Economics