Transformer mineral oil has been replaced by alternative oils such as synthetic oil and natural esters due to their biodegradability and environmentally friendly nature. This paper presents performance of coconut oil as such an alternative. Generally, as the other alternative oils, coconut oil has high conductivity due to the presence of free fatty acids. In this study, three different types of coconut oil samples consisting of virgin, copra and RBD (refined, bleached and deodorized) were initially tested by frequency dielectric spectroscopy (FDS) measurements to see how the conductivity was improved by dehydration and neutralization. The FDS results were fitted by inverse power dependence and Cole-Cole models to estimate the conductivity and response functions. Afterwards, a set of new coconut oil samples extracted from copra were thermally aged at 120°C under sealed conditions and compared with that of mineral oil. The performances of oil samples were evaluated using the test results of breakdown voltage, acidity, interfacial tension and FDS measurements under different aging periods such as 2, 5 and 7 weeks. Another 4 sets of new coconut and mineral oil samples were subjected to simulated thermal faults and electrical faults which include aging for 12 hours at 160°C, one hour at 200°C, exposing to partial discharges for four hours and subjecting to 20 low energy breakdowns. The performance comparisons were done by FDS measurements and dissolved gas analysis. In parallel, field-aged coconut oil samples collected from a sealed distribution transformer with 11 years of service were also tested by FDS measurements. In general, coconut oil shows its suitability as an alternative to the mineral oils for transformers, despite limitations found in some of their physical properties. It was found that the FDS results were in good agreement with chemical test results and with the estimated conductivity values.
5 August 2016 in IEEE Transactions on Dielectrics and Electrical Insulation
Aging of transformer paper insulation is commonly investigated through indirect measurements conducted in the oil, e.g. furanic compounds. In addition to the conventional indicators, recent investigations showed that alcohols like methanol and ethanol in oil could be used as paper aging indicators. This paper focuses on the applicability of these new paper aging indicators in a novel, gas-to-liquid (GTL) technology based transformer oil through an accelerated laboratory aging experiment. The experiment was conducted at 120 °C for up to 280 days. A conventional mineral oil was also tested as a reference. Kraft paper aged in both oil types showed similar reductions in degree of polymerization (DP) and tensile strength (TS). Amount of methanol in oil is higher than that of 2-FAL in oil when DP is over 375, confirming the promise of using methanol as an early paper aging indicator. Both the new paper aging indicator, methanol and the conventional paper aging indicator, 2-FAL are applicable for the GTL oil without any modifications. In addition, oil only aging experiments showed that oil does produce methanol but it is negligible compared with oil paper aging experiment; however the amount of ethanol measured in the present oil paper aging experiment is believed to be originated from oil oxidation rather than from paper aging.
19 April 2018 in IEEE Transactions on Dielectrics and Electrical Insulation
The applicability of using 2-furfural (2-FAL) and methanol as aging markers for synthetic ester impregnated paper insulation was investigated through laboratory aging experiments at temperatures of 80, 100 and 120 °C. Methanol in the synthetic ester increased linearly with paper aging until degree of polymerisation (DP) reached 400. During this period concentration of methanol in oil was higher than that of 2-FAL, which proved the concept of using methanol to indicate early paper aging in the synthetic ester. However, the rate of methanol increase against the reduction of DP in the synthetic ester was about three times higher than that seen in mineral oil. This is due to a difference in the partitioning of the marker between oil and paper. Since the synthetic ester is more polar than the mineral oil, it attracted more methanol molecules from the paper, resulting in a higher concentration of methanol in oil for the same reduction of DP. In addition, a reduction in methanol was observed at the later stage of paper aging at 120 °C. This could be due to either a change in the partitioning between oil and paper, or an esterification reaction which consumes methanol in the system.
Paper ageing is an irreversible process, which has made paper insulation a lifetime determining factor for transformers. Chemical indicators in oil such as carbon oxide gases and 2-FAL, are used to indicate the ageing state of paper as it is difficult to obtain paper samples to measure DP or tensile strength. Methanol amount in oil was recently found to be an early-ageing indicator for paper. In this study, a headspace gas chromatography mass spectrometry setup was developed to measure methanol in transformer oil. This setup consists of an auto sampler with a gas tight syringe, a gas chromatography unit with 60 m VF-624ms column and a quadrupole ion trap type mass spectrometer unit. Measurement of several laboratory-aged and service-aged oil samples were conducted with both external standard and internal standard calibration methods. Higher methanol values obtained from internal standard method confirmed that it is more suitable than external standard method.
Ageing assessment of transformer paper insulation is important due to its irreversible ageing nature. Due to the poor accessibility of the paper samples in field transformers, large efforts were made to seek for chemical parameters in oil to indicate paper ageing, e.g. furanic compounds and dissolved carbon oxides. In recent years, alternative parameters including methanol and ethanol in oil were proposed to be related with paper ageing. In this study, a laboratory ageing experiment was conducted at 120 °C with an inhibited mineral oil and an ordinary kraft paper. Methanol and ethanol in oil were measured through an in-house developed method based on a headspace gas chromatography mass spectrometry (HS-GC-MS) setup. Result showed that methanol in oil increases linearly with the chain scission in paper which suggests its suitability to indicate early paper ageing.
Managing a large fleet of ageing assets has become a technical challenge faced by many electricity utilities in developed countries. Asset managers are increasingly interested in techniques that can help extend the useful lifetime of a transformer. Oil regeneration is one of such techniques. In this paper, oil regeneration experiments were performed on a 6.4/0.4 kV retired distribution transformer to investigate the effect of oil regeneration on improving paper conditions. Oil regeneration was conducted in two stages, with the first stage aimed at ‘cleaning the oil’ and the second stage targeted at ‘cleaning the paper’. Oil samples were collected at regular intervals throughout the process and paper samples were obtained from the transformer before and after each oil regeneration stage. It was found that oil regeneration restores oil parameters, including moisture and acidity, similar to those of new oils at the end of stage 1. Analysis of paper samples indicated a reduction in paper moisture at the end of stage 2 by nearly 40%, while low molecular weight acids (LMA) in paper exhibited a reduction by around 30% on average. It is found that the extended oil regeneration period, i.e., stage 2, is necessary to improve the paper condition and hence to reduce the paper ageing rate.